VP Vance Praises Indian In-Laws as "Great Contributors" Amid Immigration Debate

US Vice President JD Vance, speaking at a university event, expressed love and admiration for his Indian-origin in-laws, calling them "great contributors" to America. His comments came in response to a question from an Indian-origin attendee about lengthy green card delays for H-1B visa holders. Vance argued for a dual approach, acknowledging immigrant contributions while cracking down on systemic fraud and emphasizing that citizens must prioritize US interests. His remarks highlight the administration's tougher immigration stance, coinciding with record numbers of ICE detainees.

Key Points: JD Vance on Indian In-Laws & US Immigration Policy

  • Vance praises his Indian immigrant in-laws
  • Defends tough stance on H-1B visa fraud
  • Highlights obligation to prioritize US interests
  • Remarks amid record ICE detainee levels
3 min read

VP Vance says he "loves" his Indian-origin in-laws, calls them "great contributors" to US amid immigration crackdown

US VP JD Vance calls his Indian-origin in-laws "great contributors" while defending a tough stance on H-1B visa fraud and immigration system reform.

"I love my in-laws and they're great people and they've been great contributors to the United States of America. - JD Vance"

Washington, DC, April 15

Vice President of the United States JD Vance said on Tuesday that his Indian-origin in-laws are "great contributors" to the United States, as he underlined that while the administration is taking a tough stand on immigration fraud, it also recognises the role of immigrants who have "enriched" the country.

Speaking at a Turning Point USA tour event at the University of Georgia, Vance said citizens must prioritise the interests of the United States over the country they came from.

During the interaction, an Indian-origin attendee raised concerns about delays in green cards for those on H-1B visas. She said, "I am also a daughter of a legal immigrant who came here on an H-1B visa. My mom and my dad, we've been here for over 10 years... it's been really hard like getting the green card based on everything with quotas and everything. How do we fix the immigration system for people who have been waiting for the green cards for so long and they're not getting it in time?"

Responding to the question, Vance said, "I would say you know you heard me talk about H-1B fraud because I think there is a lot of fraud in the H-1B system. And I think you can all you can believe on the one hand that there's a lot of fraud in the H-1B system while also believing that there are people who have come to the United States in the past who have enriched this country and look, I am married to the daughter of immigrants from India and, you know, I love my in-laws and they're great people and they've been great contributors to the United States of America."

He added, "But I also think that when you become an American citizen, whether your family is nine generations of lineage in the United States or whether your family has zero generations of lineage in the United States, one of the responsibilities that we must expect of citizens and I of course you know it's always hard to talk in specifics about your situation because I don't know about it but one of the obligations of citizens is that you have to think about the best interest of the country and not the country you came from before hand and not of any sort of any group that you came from you've got to think of yourself as an American."

Vance also praised his father-in-law, calling him "an amazing guy". He said, "My father-in-law is an amazing guy... father-in-law who came from India who moved to the United States who got an education and became an American citizen that never once never once in my life has he ever said 'you have to do this' or 'you should do this because it's in the best interest of the country that I came from.'"

The remarks come amid a tougher stance adopted by the administration on immigration and citizenship. In January, the number of detainees in custody of US Immigration and Customs Enforcement crossed 70,000 for the first time in the agency's 23-year history, according to internal data from the Department of Homeland Security obtained by CBS News.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

R
Rohit P
"Think about the best interest of the country and not the country you came from" – This is a fair expectation for citizens. Most Indian-Americans I know are fiercely patriotic towards the US. The issue is the decade-long wait for a green card despite following all rules. That's the real problem, not loyalty.
A
Arjun K
Classic political talk. "I love my Indian in-laws, but..." There's always a "but". The H-1B system needs reform, yes, but blanket statements about fraud hurt the thousands of skilled professionals contributing to tech and innovation. They pay taxes for years without the security of permanent residency. Fix the quotas!
S
Sarah B
As someone married to an Indian who came on an H-1B, this resonates. The journey is incredibly stressful. It's heartening to hear a public figure acknowledge the contributions, but the policy needs to match the rhetoric. The backlog is inhuman.
V
Vikram M
He's trying to have it both ways. On one hand, cracking down and talking about fraud, on the other, giving a personal example. For the administration, the personal shouldn't be an exception to the policy. The message is confusing for the diaspora.
K
Karthik V
The contribution of Indian immigrants in the US is undeniable, from Silicon Valley to medicine. The green card wait for Indians is uniquely long due to per-country caps. That's the reform needed – not just praising individual stories while maintaining a system that keeps others in limbo for 15+ years. Jai Hind.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50