MEA Slams Trump's 'Hellhole' Remark on Indians as Uninformed

The Indian government on Thursday termed a social media post by US President Donald Trump as "uninformed, inappropriate and in poor taste." The post amplified a video by Michael Savage calling India a "hellhole" regarding birthright citizenship. Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge attacked Prime Minister Narendra Modi for remaining silent on the issue. Kharge questioned what is stopping India from raising the matter at the highest levels of the American government.

Key Points: MEA Slams Trump's 'Hellhole' Remark on Indians

  • MEA calls Trump's social media post on India 'uninformed' and 'in poor taste'
  • Post features Michael Savage calling India a 'hellhole' over birthright citizenship
  • Congress chief Mallikarjun Kharge slams PM Modi for silence
  • Kharge questions India's failure to raise issue at highest US levels
3 min read

"Uninformed, inappropriate remarks...": MEA after row on Trump's social media repost

MEA calls Trump's reposted video calling India a 'hellhole' uninformed. Congress leader Kharge attacks PM Modi for silence on the issue.

"The remarks are obviously uninformed, inappropriate and in poor taste. - Randhir Jaiswal"

New Delhi, April 24

The government on Thursday said a social media post that referred to Indians in derogatory terms in terms of immigration, was "uninformed, inappropriate and in poor taste".

"We have seen the comments, as also the subsequent statement issued by the US Embassy in response. The remarks are obviously uninformed, inappropriate and in poor taste. They certainly do not reflect the reality of the India-US relationship, which has long been based on mutual respect and shared interests," MEA Spokesperon Randhir Jaiswal said.

He was responding to query about social media post that had referred, among other things, to Indians.

Earlier, during weekly media briefing, Jaiswal responded to query on the reports of US President Donald Trump endorsing a report critical of India and China over immigration.

""We've seen some reports. That's where I'll leave it," he said.

Trump amplified a critique of birthright citizenship in the US by sharing a video featuring right-wing conservative author and radio host Michael Savage on Truth Social.

In the clip, Savage criticised existing immigration laws, alleging that they allow individuals to exploit legal provisions by travelling to the US late in pregnancy to secure citizenship for their children.

In the video, Savage claimed that such practices create a loophole whereby "a baby here becomes an instant citizen", followed by family migration from countries including "China or India or some other hellhole on the planet".

The footage, originally aired on the Newsmax series The Savage Nation, was highlighted by the "Commentary Donald J. Trump Posts From Truth Social" account, which serves as a platform dedicated to reposting the President's social media activity.

In the clip, Savage expressed deep frustration with the judicial process. "Today's brief, abbreviated discussion will be about the arguments that I just listened to before the Supreme Court about birthright citizenship. I was somewhat incensed by listening to the arguments because all I heard was legalese being bandied back and forth."

Following MEA's one-line response over Trump's post, Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge launched a sharp attack on Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

In a post on X, Kharge said that Prime Minister Modi remained "absolutely mum" on the disparaging terms and questioned what was stopping India from raising the matter at the highest levels of the American government.

"Modi's dear friend, 'Namaste Trump' has shared a note abusing India and using an extremely disparaging term. Modi remains absolutely mum on these ridiculous utterances. MEA Spokesperson said, 'That is where I leave it.' Modi, what are you scared of? Indians have played a vital role in America's success. What is stopping us to raise this at the highest levels of the American government?" Kharge asked.

"From the skewed Indo-US Trade deal framework to Trump's earlier claims on mediating to stop the war during Operation Sindoor, from grinning in front of Trump when he said 'BRICS is dead' to US levying 50 per cent tariffs on India -- at every step Modi has mortgaged India's interests. Amidst the high-voltage election campaign of the Prime Minister, I sincerely hope that he gets some time to react to this intimidation and indignation of 140 crore Indians," he said.

Some other Congress leaders also commented on the government's response.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priya S
I think the MEA did fine. Diplomacy isn't about shouting back. The US embassy already distanced themselves from it. And let's be real - that Michael Savage guy is a known provocateur, and Trump just reposted without endorsement. Kharge is making political hay out of this. Focus on real issues, not social media drama.
V
Vikram M
The arrogance of these people! "Hellhole" - really? India is one of the fastest-growing economies, a nuclear power, and we're supposed to take this lying down? Trump thinks he can insult us because Modi is too chummy with him. Time to remind America that we don't need their validation. Our IT professionals and doctors built Silicon Valley.
J
James A
As an American who works with many Indian colleagues, this guy Savage represents the worst of us. But let's not overreact - Trump reposts all kinds of crazy stuff without endorsing it. The US embassy statement shows this isn't official policy. But Modi should definitely address it directly to show solidarity with Indians abroad.
K
Kavya N
I'm tired of this pattern - Trump says or does something rude about India, Modi stays silent, and then Kharge cries foul. But tell me, what exactly would raising it at the "highest levels" achieve? Trump is unpredictable. Maybe quiet diplomacy works better. But the "hellhole" comment hurts - we deserve respect, not insults.
S
Siddharth J
The real issue here isn't Trump or Kharge - it's our own government's weakness. MEA says "that's where I leave

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50