Three-Pronged Strategy to Curb Energy Shock Impact on Economy: HSBC Economist

HSBC economist Pranjul Bhandari recommends a three-pronged strategy for the Indian government to counter global energy shock impacts. The strategy includes credit guarantee schemes for small firms, expanding NREGA for rural unemployment benefits, and increasing public capital expenditure. Bhandari notes that front-loading manufacturing activity is currently masking negative growth impacts, but these will become apparent later. She also warns that an El Nino cycle could further pressure agricultural production.

Key Points: HSBC Economist: Three-Pronged Strategy for Energy Shock

  • Global energy shock threatens growth and inflation
  • Three-pronged strategy: credit guarantees, NREGA, public capex
  • Small firms and rural India need handholding
  • Front-loading manufacturing masks negative impacts temporarily
3 min read

A three-prong strategy can help govt curb energy shock implications, says HSBC Economist

HSBC economist Pranjul Bhandari suggests credit guarantees, NREGA, and public capex to mitigate global energy shock effects on India's growth.

"The government can do a lot of public capex and then they get jobs and incomes from there. - Pranjul Bhandari"

New Delhi, May 7

The central government can implement a three-pronged strategy to mitigate the implications of a global energy shock on domestic growth, according to Pranjul Bhandari, Chief India & ASEAN Economist at HSBC.

Speaking to ANI, Bhandari noted that while energy shocks typically drive prices up and growth down, the government's current focus remains on the growth aspect, as the central bank generally manages inflation. She indicated that the government is utilizing a playbook developed during the pandemic to navigate these supply-side challenges.

"I think from the government's point of view, they are thinking about it as more sort of a growth shock because generally it's the central bank in charge of inflation so they think about prices while the government is about growth....So the government can do a lot of public capex and then they get jobs and incomes from there. So I would say a three-prong strategy: credit guarantee schemes, high unemployment benefits like NREGA and number three, public capex," Bhandari said.

"My general sense is that there are a few things that the government can do. First, handhold the small firms because they are very sensitive to price increases and a lack of inputs. So they've done that with that credit guarantee scheme that they announced overnight," she added.

The economist highlighted the possibility of labourers returning to rural areas if factories reduce operations. She also cautioned that agricultural production could face additional pressure from an El Nino cycle.

"So, handhold rural India as well on the back of these unemployment benefits that you have, like NREGA, employ that. And number three, focus on public investment, public infrastructure, which is something that we started to do during the pandemic period," Bhandari added.

Explaining the logic behind public spending, she noted that when agriculture underperforms, rural workers often transition to construction for income.

Regarding recent manufacturing trends, Bhandari highlighted the rise in the April PMI manufacturing index following a dip in March. She attributed this to the diversification of energy sources and a strategic move by producers to stockpile goods.

"Many manufacturers, because they had energy input available, I think they were of the view that let's quickly produce things and stock it up. What if we don't have energy in the next few months? And we saw a lot of stockpiling. We had a lot of inventory build up," she said.

Bhandari mentioned that while this front-loading activity is currently masking some of the negative effects of the energy crisis, the impact on growth will eventually become more apparent.

"I think the big takeaway for me is that an energy shock generally is negative for growth. Eventually, I think, the shock will be negative for growth, but we may not see all of the negative impact upfront and quickly, because upfront, we are also getting the help and support of the front-loading manufacturing activity that many factories are doing. So that painful information will probably come a little later when front-loading has ended," Bhandari stated.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

V
Vikram Mhatre
Finally someone talking about rural India! NREGA is a lifeline for millions during tough times. My village in Maharashtra saw many return during COVID. The government should increase NREGA wages and ensure timely payments. Also, public infrastructure projects in rural areas will create jobs and help when agriculture suffers due to El Nino. Good suggestions but will the budget allow all this?
S
Sarah Mitchell
Being an economist working in India, I find this analysis quite balanced. The credit guarantee scheme during COVID was effective for small businesses. However, I'm skeptical about the "front-loading" benefit mentioned. Stockpiling can only mask problems temporarily. The real test will come when energy prices remain high and inventory runs out. India needs to accelerate renewable energy adoption - that's the long-term solution.
A
Arjun Krishnan
Good analysis but misses one crucial point - state government coordination. In India, many schemes fail because of friction between centre and states. For example, NREGA implementation varies hugely between Kerala and UP. The economist assumes seamless execution. Also, what about fertilizer subsidies? Farmers are already struggling with input costs. Need a fourth prong - direct agricultural support.
J
James Anderson
As someone who works in energy sector, I think HSBC economist is being too optimistic about front-loading. The energy crisis is structural, not temporary. Europe is already facing real pain. India's strategy should include more aggressive renewable targets and energy storage. The three-pronged approach is good for short-term relief but lacks vision for energy transition. Just my two cents.
R
Rohit Patel
I like that she mentioned small firms need handholding. My

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50