SC sets aside Gauhati HC order upholding some people as foreigners
New Delhi, July 14
The Supreme Court on Monday set aside a batch of Gauhati High Court orders that upheld declarations of some people as foreigners and remanded the cases to the concerned Foreigners Tribunals for fresh adjudication.
A bench of Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta made it clear that it had not examined the merits of the appellants' claims to Indian citizenship.
The bench also observed that the determination of citizenship and foreigner status "must be carried out through a fair, lawful and reasonable process".
It said that the issue of citizenship carries profound constitutional significance and must be decided in accordance with the requirements of fairness.
It also acknowledged the State's interest in preventing illegal claims to Indian citizenship.
"The State has a legitimate and compelling interest in ensuring that persons who are not legally entitled to claim Indian citizenship do not secure such status by misuse of process, by false claims, or by taking advantage of procedural delay," the judgement stated.
The bench directed the concerned persons to appear before the concerned Foreigners Tribunals within four weeks from the date of the order.
They have also been granted liberty to file their written statements, documentary evidence and all supporting materials in support of their claim to Indian citizenship before the Tribunals.
The Foreigners Tribunals have further been asked to conclude the fresh adjudication preferably within six months, in accordance with the law.
"Until fresh opinions are rendered by the concerned Tribunals, no coercive steps shall be taken against the appellants on the basis of the opinions which have been set aside by this judgment, subject to the appellants appearing before the concerned Tribunals and cooperating with the proceedings," the verdict added.
The Gauhati High Court had dismissed the challenge to an ex parte order of the Foreigners Tribunal declaring the petitioners to be foreigners. The High Court had noted that none of the appellants appeared before a Tribunal even after they were served with notices.
These cases originated from orders passed by various Foreigners Tribunals in Assam.
— ANI
Reader Comments
But the Gauhati HC pointed out that these people didn't even appear before the Tribunal! That's a big red flag. I understand giving a second chance, but this also delays the process for genuine cases. Assam has its own unique challenges with illegal immigration. Hope the Tribunals act fast now.
Interesting case from a legal perspective. The SC is balancing between preventing illegal claims and ensuring due process. The six-month deadline for fresh adjudication is sensible. Let's see how the new hearings go.
Honestly, this Supreme Court bench is doing great work on fundamental rights. But I'm worried about the practical impact. There are already so many pending cases before Foreigners Tribunals in Assam. Will these fresh hearings even happen in time, or will it just be another round of adjournments?
The SC's observation that "citizenship carries profound constitutional significance" is spot on. India's citizenship laws are already complex enough, and we can't afford to have procedural flaws causing wrongful denials. At the same time, we can't let the system be exploited. It's a tightrope walk.
My heart goes out to people caught in these cases. Imagine being declared a foreigner without even getting a chance to present your documents! The SC is right to give them a fresh opportunity. But I also think the government needs to strengthen the Foreigners Tribunals - more judges, better infrastructure, clearer guidelines.
<
We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.