Pakistan's Sanitation Workers Face Caste, Gender Discrimination and Neglect

A report highlights the severe institutional neglect and discrimination faced by sanitation workers in Pakistan, rooted in entrenched caste hierarchies. Workers, predominantly from Christian and Hindu communities, perform hazardous duties without legal protections or safety enforcement, leading to injuries and deaths. Women sanitation workers face compounded "triple discrimination" based on caste, religion, and gender, resulting in lower pay and greater stigma. The crisis is described as one of Pakistan's most entrenched yet least acknowledged human rights violations.

Key Points: Sanitation Workers in Pakistan Face Systemic Discrimination

  • Caste-designated inherited work
  • Hazardous conditions & deaths
  • Gendered 'triple discrimination'
  • Extreme economic marginalization
3 min read

Sanitation workers in Pakistan face institutional neglect and discrimination: Report

A report details the caste-based, gendered exploitation and institutional neglect faced by Pakistan's sanitation workers, calling it a human rights crisis.

"Sanitation work in Pakistan exists at the crossroads of caste, class, religion, and gender - European Times Report"

Islamabad, March 11

Pakistan's sanitation workers endure hardship driven by entrenched caste hierarchies, discriminatory hiring, absence of legal protections, institutional neglect, social stigma, gendered exploitation, and economic injustice. Their suffering is deeply embedded in the fabric of the state and society, rendering it largely invisible, a report said on Tuesday.

According to a report in the European Times, with their labour sustaining cities, preventing disease, and upholding public health, sanitation workers across Pakistan deserve dignity, safety, fair wages, and equal rights - not as charity, but as justice.

"Sanitation work in Pakistan exists at the crossroads of caste, class, religion, and gender, forming one of the country's most entrenched and least acknowledged human rights crises. The people who keep Pakistan's cities functioning by cleaning streets, unclogging drains, and descending into sewers are treated as expendable. Their labour is indispensable, yet their lives are consistently devalued. For women sanitation workers, the burden is even heavier, shaped by a 'triple discrimination' rooted in caste, religion, and gender," the report detailed.

"Sanitation work is not merely a profession in Pakistan; it is a caste-designated occupation inherited through generations. The majority of workers come from so-called 'lower-caste' Christian and Hindu communities, pushed into this work by discriminatory recruitment practices and the absence of real employment alternatives," it added.

Citing Pakistan's National Commission for Human Rights (NCHR) findings titled 'Risk of Sanitation Work in Pakistan', the report documented "widespread injuries, deaths, and unsafe conditions", reflecting the lack of a comprehensive national health-and-safety system.

"Without regulatory enforcement or emergency response mechanisms, workers are routinely exposed to hazardous environments and toxic gases. The continued deaths of Christian labourers engaged in manual scavenging constitute a grave violation of fundamental rights and a persistent failure of the state to fulfil its constitutional obligations," it mentioned.

According to the report, Pakistan's Supreme Court has questioned if public office has become "mere evasion of duty," and asked whether sewerage workers' lives are regarded as less valuable than those of other citizens.

"For women sanitation workers, the crisis deepens. They face the same caste - and religion-based discrimination as their male counterparts, but with the added burden of gendered exploitation. Amnesty International describes their situation as 'triple discrimination', capturing the compounded vulnerabilities they endure. Women workers often earn far below the legal minimum wage, and face heightened social stigma, limited mobility, and greater barriers to accessing social protection schemes," it stated.

Highlighting the discrimination, the report further said, "Economic marginalisation is a defining feature of sanitation work in Pakistan. Even as workers perform some of the most essential and dangerous labour in the country, they are among the lowest paid."

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

R
Rohit P
Very disturbing report. It's ironic that a country which often lectures others on human rights has such a deep-rooted, institutionalised problem within its own society. The Supreme Court's question is valid - are some lives considered less valuable? This needs more global attention.
A
Aman W
As an Indian, I feel we must look at our own backyard too. Manual scavenging is still a reality here, though laws exist. This report from Pakistan shows the problem is systemic where minority communities are forced into this work. Dignity of labour should be universal. 🙏
S
Sarah B
The gendered exploitation detail is chilling. Earning below minimum wage, limited mobility, extra stigma... it's a cycle of oppression. The report calling it a "human rights crisis" is accurate. Where are the international human rights bodies on this?
V
Vikram M
The article mentions Christian and Hindu communities being pushed into this work. It's a clear case of religious minority persecution. While the focus is on Pakistan, it's a reminder for all South Asian nations to eradicate such feudal practices and ensure mechanisation and safety for all sanitation work.
K
Karthik V
A respectful criticism: The article is important, but the source is "European Times". We should also seek reports from local Pakistani activists and journalists for a more grounded perspective. Change must be driven from within the society, not just by external reports.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50