Goyal Slams Congress' "Sour Grapes" Criticism of Historic India-EU Trade Deal

Union Minister Piyush Goyal has strongly rebutted Congress leader Jairam Ramesh's criticism of the India-European Union Free Trade Agreement, labeling the allegations as "sour grapes." Goyal emphasized that the deal unites economies with a combined GDP of $25 trillion and will create a plethora of opportunities for Indian businesses and people. He addressed specific concerns on sectors like automobiles, steel, and intellectual property, stating the government is proactively protecting exporters' interests. The Minister framed the FTA as a long-term strategic engagement based on trust that will power India's economic growth.

Key Points: Piyush Goyal Defends India-EU FTA, Rejects Congress Criticism

  • Rejects criticism as "sour grapes"
  • Highlights $25 trillion combined GDP market
  • Addresses CBAM, auto, and IP concerns
  • Stresses deal will boost 'Make in India'
3 min read

Piyush Goyal rejects Congress criticism on India-EU FTA, calls deal win-win and growth-oriented

Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal counters Congress's Jairam Ramesh, calling the India-EU FTA a win-win deal for growth, jobs, and exports.

"It is not a zero sum deal but a win-win deal which will power our economic growth - Piyush Goyal"

New Delhi, January 29

Union Commerce and Industry Minister Piyush Goyal has strongly rejected the criticism levelled by Congress leader Jairam Ramesh on the India-European Union Free Trade Agreement, calling the allegations a case of "sour grapes" and asserting that the agreement is a win-win deal for both India and the EU.

Responding to the charges, Goyal said it was surprising to see criticism from those who could not take timely decisions when they were in power and had no connection with people on the ground.

He said the country had paid a heavy price for such inaction in the past.

Goyal in a social media post, stated, "Our country has lost valuable jobs, income and growth and people have rightly punished this inaction many times".

Answering to the claim of Jairam Ramesh thatthe agreement is "hugely hyped", Goyal said the deal brings together economies with a combined GDP of USD 25 trillion.

He said, "Is the combined GDP of USD 25 trillion, combined global trade of USD 11 trillion and common market of 2 billion people, USD 33 billion of India's labour-intensive exports going to zero on day 1 a hype?".

He added, "It is not a zero sum deal but a win-win deal which will power our economic growth and create plethora of opportunities for our businesses and people"

Congress leader Jairam Ramesh, in a social media post on Wednesday, raised concerns over CBAM, falling aluminium and steel exports, strict EU health and safety norms, IP issues, access to services, risks to the auto and EV sectors, and uncertainty over refined fuel exports sourced from Russia.

On concerns related to the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM), Goyal said the government has taken up the issue of exporters' interests in steel, aluminium and other sectors like no one ever has.

He said India has identified pathways to address these complex issues through dialogue, trust and cooperation, rather than rigid positions.

On automobiles, Goyal said the quota-based, premium-segment-focused and phased auto offer, including a five-year time lag for EVs, is aimed at boosting Make in India. Liberalising CKD imports will encourage EU OEMs to set up local assembly, eventually leading to full localisation, advanced manufacturing, higher safety and better technology standards.

(CKD) Completely Knocked Down Kit, refers to a method where a vehicle is exported or imported as completely disassembled parts rather than a finished unit.

Addressing fears around regulations, Goyal said all countries, including India, retain the right to regulate for health and safety. He said such measures are disciplined under the agreement to ensure they do not become unjustified trade barriers.

On intellectual property rights, he clarified that obligations are similar to TRIPS (Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights) under the WTO, with emphasis on public health flexibilities, technology transfer, recognition of India's traditional digital knowledge library, and preservation of India's data exclusivity policy.

He also said concerns about refined fuel are linked to extraneous reasons and stressed that the India-EU FTA is a long-term strategic engagement based on trust and mutual respect.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

S
Sarah B
While the economic potential is huge, Jairam Ramesh raises valid points about CBAM and strict EU norms. Our steel and aluminium industries need concrete support, not just assurances. Hope the dialogue yields real results for exporters.
P
Priya S
Good to see emphasis on protecting our traditional knowledge and data policies. The IPR part was a big worry. If it's truly aligned with TRIPS and allows for public health flexibilities, that's a relief. Long-term trust is key.
R
Rohit P
The phased approach for EVs and auto is smart. It gives our industry time to adapt. If EU companies set up assembly here, it will create jobs and boost manufacturing. Let's hope the execution matches the vision.
K
Karthik V
The "sour grapes" comment was unnecessary. Healthy debate is good for democracy. We should focus on the deal's details—like how it handles agriculture and dairy, which affect millions of farmers. That's more important than political jibes.
M
Michael C
A market of 2 billion people is no joke. This could be India's gateway to becoming a true global export hub. The focus on labour-intensive exports is crucial for job creation. Hope the benefits trickle down to small businesses.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50