NewKerala.com

Pakistan's Economic Freedom Claims Collide With Harsh Reality Check

A recent analysis challenges Pakistan's official narrative of economic stabilization, highlighting its persistently low ranking on global economic freedom indices. The report points to a sharp contradiction where a low tax-to-GDP ratio masks a high effective tax burden on compliant individuals and businesses. Furthermore, the economy is dominated by informal employment, which suppresses productivity and limits the revenue base. While there are positive signs like moderated inflation, lasting gains depend on strengthening institutions and ensuring predictable, fair rules for business.

Key Points: Pakistan's Economic Freedom: Official Claims vs. Harsh Reality

  • Low global economic freedom ranking
  • Contradiction in high tax burden vs. low tax-to-GDP
  • Dominance of informal employment
  • Governance and judicial reliability concerns
  • Modest reforms overshadowed by structural weaknesses
2 min read

Pakistan's economic freedom claims face hard reality check

Analysis reveals Pakistan's low economic freedom ranking, with structural issues in taxation, informality, and governance undermining reform narratives.

"reform announcements on one side, entrenched vulnerabilities on the other - The Express Tribune"

Islamabad Februar, y 10

A recent analysis paints a complicated and often uncomfortable picture of Pakistan's standing on economic freedom, suggesting that official narratives of stabilisation are colliding with persistent structural weaknesses, as reported by The Express Tribune.

According to The Express Tribune, global measurements continue to place Pakistan among the lower-ranked economies, with long-standing concerns about governance, judicial reliability and market dynamism still weighing heavily. While authorities argue that the worst phase of the inflation crisis has passed and reform momentum is building, critics say improvements on paper have yet to transform daily economic life. Investors remain wary, particularly where contract enforcement and political influence over institutions are perceived to be unresolved.

One of the sharpest contradictions lies in taxation. International methodologies may interpret Pakistan's low tax-to-GDP ratio as evidence of a lighter burden. However, people and firms already inside the net report the opposite experience. Higher marginal income tax rates and the continuation of additional corporate levies have significantly increased pressure on compliant sectors, raising questions about how "freedom" is actually felt in the marketplace.

Employment patterns further complicate the outlook. Informality dominates, with the overwhelming majority of workers operating outside documented arrangements. Economists warn this suppresses productivity, narrows the revenue base and leaves millions without safety nets. Such figures are troubling for a country seeking sustainable development and export competitiveness, as cited by The Express Tribune.

There are, undeniably, brighter spots. Price growth has moderated, privatisation efforts have re-entered policy discussions, and tariff rationalisation signals greater openness. Yet observers caution that without parallel institutional strengthening, these steps may not deliver lasting gains. Pakistan's trajectory appears mixed: reform announcements on one side, entrenched vulnerabilities on the other. Whether future assessments improve will depend on implementation, credibility and the state's ability to convince businesses that rules are predictable, fair and insulated from politics, as reported by The Express Tribune.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

S
Sarah B
As someone who follows South Asian economies, the parallels and contrasts with India's own journey are stark. We've had our struggles with informality and tax compliance too. The key difference seems to be the predictability of rules. Investors need that above all else. 🤔
R
Rohit P
The article hits the nail on the head. "Reform announcements on one side, entrenched vulnerabilities on the other." Sound familiar? It's a lesson for all developing nations, including ours. Stabilization headlines are easy, fixing the plumbing of the economy is the real test.
A
Ananya R
It's the common people who suffer the most in these situations. High inflation, lack of safety nets for informal workers... these are human issues, not just economic metrics. I hope for the sake of their citizens that the institutional strengthening happens soon. 🙏
K
Karthik V
A respectful criticism: while we analyse our neighbour's economy, we must look inward with the same lens. Our tax-to-GDP ratio is also a challenge, and contract enforcement in our courts can be slow. It's a regional issue of governance we all need to solve.
M
Michael C
The point about investors being wary due to political influence is crucial. No amount of tariff rationalization matters if the rules change with the government. Economic freedom starts with separating policy from politics—a tough task anywhere, but essential.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50