Pakistan Deemed "Unreliable" US Ally, "Extremely Problematic" Partner in Report

A Gatestone Institute report argues Pakistan has proven to be an unreliable strategic partner for the United States despite its privileged ally status. The analysis points to Pakistan's longstanding preference for Iran, including its refusal to recognize Israel and its support for Tehran during a 2025 conflict with a US-Israel coalition. The report details deep cooperation between Pakistan and Iran on issues like countering Baloch activism and integrating with China's Belt and Road Initiative. It concludes that Pakistan's actions warrant a serious reconsideration of its Major Non-NATO Ally privileges by Washington.

Key Points: Report Labels Pakistan an Unreliable US Ally

  • Major Non-NATO Ally status questioned
  • Strategic alignment with Iran highlighted
  • Support for Iran during 2025 conflict
  • Shared China economic interests
  • Balochistan policy convergence
3 min read

Pakistan 'unreliable' US ally, 'extremely problematic' partner: Report

A think tank report states Pakistan is an "extremely problematic" partner for the US, citing its alignment with Iran over Washington.

"Pakistan should be viewed not as a dependable ally, but as an extremely problematic partner - Gatestone Institute Report"

Washington, Jan 8

Although Pakistan enjoys Major Non-NATO Ally status with the United States, which grants privileged access to military cooperation and equipment, Islamabad has consistently proven to be an unreliable strategic partner, a report highlighted on Thursday.

It added that Pakistan should be viewed not as a dependable ally, but as an extremely problematic partner, warranting serious reconsideration of its MNNA privilege status.

According to a report of the New York-based think tank Gatestone Institute, Pakistan's leadership preference for Iran over the United States - not to mention Israel - underscores why Washington cannot trust Islamabad, especially on issues related to Gaza.

"Pakistan has, to this day, never recognised Israel. Pakistan was also the first country to recognise the Islamic Republic of Iran after Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini established it in 1979. Iran had been the first country to recognise Pakistan upon its founding in 1947. Bilateral trade between the neighbouring countries 'stands at around US$2.8 billion'," it stated.

The report stressed that Pakistan officially presents its ties with Iran as one of fraternity and shared regional interests, with considerable convergence in their policy priorities.

"Convergence is their shared approach toward Balochistan, where both governments perceive Baloch political activism as a direct threat to territorial integrity and state authority. In November 2024, the late Major General Hossein Salami, then commander of Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), met with Pakistan's Army Chief Asim Munir, who oversees operations of the Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI). The two pledged enhanced cooperation against the Baloch independence movements," it mentioned.

The report further said, "This alignment is further reinforced by shared economic interests with China. The China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) constitutes one of the flagship components of China's Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). Iran wants integration into BRI and CPEC."

It emphasised that the latest demonstration of Pakistan's alignment with Iran came during the June 2025 12-day war - a direct armed conflict between Iran and a coalition of Israel and the United States. Throughout the conflict, Pakistan stood firmly with Iran, declaring its unequivocal support for Tehran.

Following the war, Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian made his first foreign trip, visiting Pakistan on August 2-3, 2025. The visit, the report said, was hailed as a major success by officials, think tanks and media in both countries, underscoring ambitions to elevate annual bilateral trade.

"These developments, coming just weeks after a conflict in which the United States and Israel directly attacked Iranian targets, highlight Pakistan's consistent pattern of prioritising regional and ideological ties with Tehran over its strategic commitments to Washington," it noted.

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priya S
The part about Balochistan is very telling. Both Pakistan and Iran suppress the Baloch people's rights. Their "cooperation" is based on mutual insecurity, not shared values. The world should pay more attention to the human rights situation there.
R
Rohit P
From an Indian security perspective, a Pakistan deeply entangled with Iran and China is a major concern. CPEC itself passes through disputed territory. The US finally waking up to Pakistan's unreliability is good, but very late.
S
Sarah B
While the report's conclusions seem valid, I hope this doesn't lead to further destabilization in the region. A cornered Pakistan is not in anyone's interest, especially for neighboring countries like India. Diplomacy should still be the priority.
K
Karthik V
The US created this monster by funding their military for years, ignoring their support for cross-border terrorism. Now they complain? Karma is a circle. India has been saying this for years. Better late than never for Washington to realize.
M
Michael C
Interesting analysis. The Iran-Pakistan-China axis is a significant geopolitical bloc. The US needs a coherent South Asia policy that doesn't just swing between engagement and alienation. A stable Afghanistan and a strong India-US partnership are key counters.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50