NCW forms panel to review laws governing IVF clinics
New Delhi, July 9
The National Commission for Women has constituted a committee, led by the former Delhi High Court Judge Asha Menon, to review the regulatory framework and laws governing IVF clinics and Assisted Reproductive Technology centres, an official said on Thursday.
The NCW said that the committee will propose Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) and best practices for ART clinics and IVF Centres to promote ethical treatment practices, standardised clinical protocol and greater transparency across the sector.
The multidisciplinary composition of the committee is intended to ensure a comprehensive examination of legal, ethical, medical and administrative issues associated with assisted reproductive technologies amid growing concerns over irregularities, the NCW said in a statement.
The panel brings together experts from judiciary, medicine, forensic science, law enforcement, gynaecology, public policy and the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare.
The committee will review the implementation of the Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act, 2021, the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021, and the relevant Amendment Rules notified in 2026, an NCW statement said.
It will examine existing safeguards relating to consent, privacy and biological traceability, identify regulatory and procedural gaps that may enable exploitation or fraudulent practices and recommend reforms to strengthen institutional accountability, it added.
The recommendations of the committee are expected to guide future legal; policy and administrative reforms aimed at strengthening governance of the ART ecosystem while ensuring that women seeking fertility treatment are protected by the robust safeguards at every stage of the process.
The NCW reiterated that reproductive healthcare must be guided by the principles of dignity, informed choice, transparency and accountability and that every woman accessing assisted reproductive services must be assured of safety, ethical treatment and protection of her rights.
While registration under the National ART and Surrogacy Registry is mandatory for all RT Clinics and Gamete Banks, the commission has said that regulatory compliance alone has not been sufficient to prevent unethical practices.
The emergence of medical tourism in the fertility sector has also raised concerns about the possible circumvention of India's legal safeguards, including those aimed at preventing sex selection, the statement said.
The absence of uniform treatment protocols across states has further highlighted the need for stronger oversight to protect women from unnecessary procedures, inconsistent standards of care and financial exploitation, it added.
— IANS
Reader Comments
As someone who went through three failed IVF cycles, I appreciate this move. The emotional and financial toll is immense. But I hope the committee includes voices of patients too - not just experts. Also, privacy of donor records and biological traceability are critical. We need laws that protect women, not just regulate clinics. 👶💪
Interesting move by NCW. India has become a hub for fertility tourism, but without proper oversight, it's risky. The 2021 Acts were a start, but clearly they need updates. Glad to see ex-judge Asha Menon leading - her legal expertise will help. Uniform treatment protocols across states is long overdue.
Good step, but I'm skeptical. Government panels often take years to submit reports. Meanwhile, clinics keep exploiting desperate couples. My neighbour spent ₹15 lakhs on IVF at a so-called 'premium' clinic in Mumbai - they kept her on unnecessary hormones for months. We need fast implementation, not just recommendations. 🤨
As a healthcare professional, I welcome this review. The ART sector in India is a wild west - inconsistent standards between states, questionable practices in gamete banking, and weak consent protocols. The NCW focus on dignity and informed choice is crucial. Let's hope the 2026 amendment rules actually get enforced this time.
This is long overdue! My aunt had to travel to three states for proper IVF treatment because each clinic had different protocols. Also, the sex selection concern is real - some clinics abroad are exploiting medical tourism to bypass Indian laws. Stronger oversight is needed. NCW
We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.