Met Sheikh Hasina in 2014, explained importance of credible elections, says SY Quraishi (IANS Exclusive)
New Delhi, July 14
Former Chief Election Commissioner S.Y. Quraishi on Tuesday recalled his meetings with former Bangladesh Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina, saying he had discussed with her the importance of maintaining the credibility and independence of the Election Commission.
Reflecting on their interactions, Quraishi said Hasina was initially "a bit defensive" but remained receptive to his views on the need for credible elections.
Recalling the circumstances that led to the meeting, Quraishi told IANS: "In 2014, I had retired already for 2 years, so I was going to Bangladesh for some lecture. But the then High Commissioner of Bangladesh in India said: 'Sir, if you are meeting Sheikh Hasina, please tell her the importance of the Election Commission and its credibility'. So, that was very important and significant."
He said he subsequently sought a courtesy meeting with Sheikh Hasina, which she readily agreed to. According to Quraishi, he attended the meeting along with the then Indian High Commissioner to Bangladesh, Pankaj Saran, while Hasina was accompanied by seven of her senior advisors.
"I sought an appointment, a courtesy call with Sheikh Hasina, and she readily agreed. I went with my High Commissioner, Pankaj Saran. She came with seven of her top advisors as if it was a formal meeting and a summit. I was just a retired CEC, but India had that image and that reputation that even a retired CEC enjoys a lot of respect and credibility," he said.
Quraishi said the meeting lasted for more than an hour, during which he explained why public confidence in the Election Commission and the conduct of credible elections were essential for a democracy.
"She (Hasina) was a bit defensive, but also receptive to the idea. And this was a very nice meeting; then we met ten years later just before this recent controversial election, and then she looked a little tired, and then she complained that she suspects that foreign powers are trying to unseat her; they want a change of regime. So, which is exactly what happened," Quraishi added.
Quraishi's remarks came against the backdrop of the release of his latest book, 'India and I: A Hundred Memories, Not a Memoir', in which he has also written about his interactions with the former Bangladesh Prime Minister.
In the book, he recounts another meeting with Sheikh Hasina in late 2023, when he visited Bangladesh as the head of an election observers' delegation ahead of the country's general elections. He wrote that the then Prime Minister appeared "visibly strained" during their interaction.
Reflecting on that conversation in his book, Quraishi writes, "She spoke bluntly about what she saw as external attempts, particularly by the United States, to engineer regime change."
— IANS
Reader Comments
I find it interesting that Quraishi mentioned the US trying to engineer regime change in Bangladesh. External interference in our neighbourhood is a real concern. But at the same time, Hasina's government should have ensured free and fair elections. Democracy without credibility is just a facade. India's Election Commission is a gold standard, and we should be proud.
Kudos to Quraishi for speaking up! But I also feel a bit sad that even after 10 years, the situation in Bangladesh hasn't improved much. Hasina's complaint about foreign powers trying to unseat her sounds like a classic deflection tactic. A strong election commission would have nullified any such conspiracy theories. India should continue to lead by example.
While I appreciate Quraishi's efforts, I do think we need to be careful about how we project ourselves. India's own elections are not perfect - we still have issues with EVMs, voter intimidation, and money power. Before advising others, we should clean our own house first. Nevertheless, the message about independent EC is universal. Good to see such diplomatic engagements.
SY Quraishi is a true statesman. Even after retirement, he continues to serve democracy. His observation about Hasina being "visibly strained" in 2023 is telling. She was probably under immense pressure from all sides. But credible elections would have given her government the legitimacy to counter any external threats. Leadership without strong institutions is fragile.
Very interesting to read about the Bangladesh angle. I think India's soft power and experience with democracy can be a great asset for our neighbours. Quraishi's
We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.