NewKerala.com

Ashes Spin Crisis: Why Sydney's Empty Pitch Worries Future Spinners

Former Australian opener Simon Katich is concerned about the future of spin bowling in Test cricket. He was reacting to both Australia and England not picking a frontline spinner for the Sydney Ashes Test. Katich pointed out this is the first time since 1888 Australia hasn't played a spinner at the SCG. He worries this trend in unsuitable conditions will hinder the development of the next generation of spinners.

Key Points: Simon Katich Worried for Next-Gen Spinners After SCG Omission

  • Australia omitted a spinner at the SCG for the first time since 1888
  • England also left their frontline spinner Shoaib Bashir out of the XI
  • Katich says conditions are dictating selections, not selector blame
  • The trend raises concerns about developing spin talent for future Tests
2 min read

Katich feels Aus, Eng opting for all-pace attack is 'worrying sign for next-gen spinners'

Former Aussie batter Simon Katich calls the lack of spinners at the SCG a "worrying sign" for developing future Test match spin bowlers.

Katich feels Aus, Eng opting for all-pace attack is 'worrying sign for next-gen spinners'
"It's a really worrying sign in terms of how we are going to develop the next generation of spinners - Simon Katich"

New Delhi, Jan 4

With neither Australia nor England selecting a frontline spinner for the fifth Ashes Test at the SCG, former Australia batter Simon Katich views this as a crucial shift in how spin bowlers are utilised in Australia.

Despite both teams having full-time spinners, Australia's Todd Murphy and England's Shoaib Bashir, neither chose to include them in their starting lineups. Murphy's omission is especially notable because it marks the first time since 1888 that Australia did not field a spinner at the SCG.

For the fourth time in the past six Test matches, and the first time since 1888 in the history of SCG Tests, the hosts have not included a full-time spinner. This situation has raised concerns among the former Australian opener about its potential impact on the development of future spin bowlers.

"It's amazing to think that both teams are without a front-line spinner (for a Sydney Test). I know in my time that would have been absolutely unheard of. But you can't blame the selectors or Steve Smith for going down the track they have," Katich told SEN Cricket.

"Because you look at the conditions and you think, 'Well, unless this deteriorates significantly in the next day or so, because this Test might only last three and a bit days'. So, it's a really worrying sign in terms of how we are going to develop the next generation of spinners to play Test Cricket for Australia if we keep playing in conditions around the country where none of them are suitable to bowl for any length of time. It's a worrying trend," he added.

The action from the SCG will continue on Monday, with England having finished Day 1 on 211/3, courtesy of an unbeaten 154-run fourth-wicket partnership between Joe Root and Harry Brook. While the former remained not out, scoring 72, the latter scored an unbeaten 78 to help the visitors recover from an early collapse.

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priya S
It's all about the conditions, isn't it? Selectors are just playing to the pitch. But he's right, it's a short-term fix. Long-term, how do you develop a world-class spinner if you never give them a game in their own country? Feel for Todd Murphy.
R
Rohit P
As an Indian fan, I see this as an advantage for our team when we tour there next 😉. But seriously, it's bad for the game. Test cricket needs variety – pace, swing, AND spin. A match with only fast bowlers gets one-dimensional.
S
Sarah B
Interesting perspective. In England, we've seen similar debates about all-rounders vs specialists. The game is evolving, but we must protect the different skills. A world where only one type of bowler thrives would be a poorer sport.
V
Vikram M
First time since 1888! That stat alone tells you how significant this is. It's not just about this Test; it's about the message it sends to kids picking up a cricket ball. Why would you want to be a spinner if even the iconic SCG doesn't need one?
K
Karthik V
While I understand the concern, I have to respectfully disagree with the alarm. Cricket is pragmatic. You pick the best team for the conditions. Maybe the focus should be on preparing more balanced pitches in Australia, not forcing spinners into teams where they won't be effective. 🤔

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50