NewKerala.com

PoGB Judicial Crisis: Supreme Appellate Court Vacancies Unfilled for 10 Years

Vacancies in the Pakistan-occupied Gilgit-Baltistan Supreme Appellate Court have remained unfilled for a decade, creating a severe judicial crisis. The court has been effectively non-functional since 2016, operating without its required quorum of three judges. This has resulted in a backlog of tens of thousands of unresolved cases, including critical public importance and criminal appeals. The legal community staged prolonged protests demanding appointments, which fall under the authority of the Prime Minister of Pakistan.

Key Points: PoGB Supreme Court Vacancies Cause Decade-Long Judicial Crisis

  • Court quorum incomplete since 2016
  • Tens of thousands of cases pending
  • Single judge cannot hear cases
  • Appointment power lies with Pakistan PM
  • Legal community staged 9-month protests
2 min read

Judicial crisis deepens in PoGB as Supreme Appellate Court vacancies remain unfilled for 10 years

For 10 years, vacancies in PoGB's Supreme Appellate Court have left it non-functional, causing a massive backlog of thousands of pending cases.

"The Supreme Appellate Court has effectively been non-functional since 2016. - Adnan Hussain"

Gilgit, March 30

Despite commitments from the federal government and a directive by the Supreme Court of Pakistan, vacant posts in the Pakistan-occupied Gilgit-Baltistan Supreme Appellate Court have remained unfilled for the past decade, according to a report by Dawn.

Legal experts have described the situation as a judicial crisis in the region, with tens of thousands of cases pending for years in the highest court. The PoGB Supreme Appellate Court, the region's apex judicial body, consists of a chief judge and two other judges.

Senior lawyer Adnan Hussain stated that the court's quorum has remained incomplete since the death of Judge Shahbaz Khan in 2016, after which the vacancy was not filled. Subsequently, another judge, Javed Ahmed, retired in 2018. Although one position was later filled when PoGB Chief Court judge Wazir Shakeel was elevated to the Supreme Appellate Court, he retired in 2021 after completing three years in office, as cited in the Dawn report.

Adnan Hussain further said that due to the incomplete quorum of three judges, the Supreme Appellate Court has effectively been non-functional since 2016. He noted that several cases cannot be heard by a two-member bench, and for the past six years, the court has been operating with only one judge.

Under existing rules, a single judge in the PoGB Supreme Appellate Court is not authorised to hear cases, leading to thousands of significant cases remaining unresolved. Another lawyer, Hafeezur Rehman, explained that under the PoGB law, the authority to appoint judges to the higher judiciary lies with the Prime Minister of Pakistan, who serves as the chairman of the PoGB Council.

He added that thousands of cases, many of public importance, are pending, including service-related appeals, disputes over promotions and seniority, and criminal appeals against decisions of the PoGB Chief Court, highlighted the Dawn report.

He also mentioned that completing the court's quorum is a major demand of the local population. Last year, the legal community in PoGB staged protests for nine months, boycotting court proceedings and organising demonstrations across the region to press for appointments in the Supreme Appellate Court. The protests were initiated by the Gilgit-Baltistan Bar Council, the PoGB Supreme Appellate Court Bar Association, and the High Court Bar Associations of all ten districts.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

S
Sarah B
As someone who values a functional judiciary, this is shocking. Tens of thousands of lives are on hold. The protests by the legal community for nine months show how desperate the situation is. The PM's office needs to act immediately.
V
Vikram M
Very sad state of affairs. While we in India have our own judicial delays, at least the courts are functional. A single judge for an entire appellate court since 2016? It's an insult to the people living there. Their fundamental right to appeal is gone.
R
Rohit P
This is the reality of the so-called "administrative control" from Islamabad. Promises are made but never fulfilled for the people of Gilgit-Baltistan. When will their voices be heard? The local bar associations are fighting a brave battle.
P
Priya S
A decade is not a delay, it's deliberate neglect. Criminal appeals, service disputes—people's careers and lives are stuck. It's a humanitarian issue beyond politics. Hope the international community takes note.
M
Michael C
Reading this from a legal perspective, the structural flaw is apparent. Why does the authority lie solely with the Pakistani PM? There should be a more robust, time-bound appointment process to prevent such a complete collapse of an institution.
K
Kavya N

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50