Iran Will Negotiate "On Their Own Terms," Says Ex-Diplomat on US Overtures

Former diplomat Vidya Bhushan Soni responded to US President Donald Trump's statement that Iran is "begging for a deal," calling the remarks contradictory. Soni asserted that Iran cannot have conditions imposed by America and will only negotiate on its own terms due to national pride and history. He explained that both sides are currently stating their maximum positions as part of a pre-negotiation phase. Actual talks, involving mutual concessions, will begin only after establishing a common acceptable denominator.

Key Points: Ex-Diplomat: Iran to Negotiate on Its Terms, Rejects US Conditions

  • Iran rejects US-imposed conditions
  • Trump's remarks seen as contradictory
  • Negotiations require give and take
  • Both sides currently positioning
3 min read

"Iran will come to the negotiating table on their own terms": Former diplomat Vidya Bhushan Soni on US' peace overtures

Former diplomat Vidya Bhushan Soni analyzes US-Iran tensions, stating Iran will not accept imposed terms and will come to the table on its own conditions.

"Iran will come to the negotiating table on their own terms. - Vidya Bhushan Soni"

New Delhi, March 28

Former diplomat Vidya Bhushan Soni on Friday said that Iran is unlikely to accept conditions imposed by the United States, calling recent remarks by US President Donald Trump contradictory and part of a broader negotiating strategy.

Reacting to Trump's statement that Iran is "begging for a deal," Soni said, "I think it's amazing. I also watched the meeting with the cabinet, which President Trump held yesterday. And was quite amazed how the same president can contradict himself in the same statement. On the one hand, he is asking Iran to come to the negotiating table; otherwise, they will be destroyed. On the other hand, they are saying they are great negotiators, if you had seen the statement which he made. And then he's putting his own conditions."

He added, "So as far as the conditions are concerned, I don't think America can impose those conditions. Iran will come to the negotiating table on their own terms. They can bear the loss, they can keep on bombarding their facilities, they can keep on destroying their things which they have. But they will not barter away their self-pride because Iran is a proud nation. It has a whole history and culture, and civilisation behind it."

Soni emphasised that both sides are currently positioning themselves ahead of any formal talks. "So you can put your conditions, yes, but to that, there are counter conditions which Iran has put," he said.

Explaining the dynamics of negotiations, he said, "This is the purpose of negotiators. You have two situations, all diametrically opposite to each other. How can we narrow them down to an issue where it is acceptable to both sides? Which means there is give and take. Give and take will be by both sides," he said.

He further described the process as a phased exchange of positions before formal dialogue begins. "At the present moment, therefore, the two sides are putting their front position, the first position which they want. And once they know each other, they will do their own homework, and they will consider maybe discuss with the concerned authorities to decide to what extent they can give in and how they can ask for a counter to that," Soni said.

According to him, actual negotiations would only begin once both sides establish basic rules and identify a "common denominator" acceptable to each.

"But that's a negotiating ploy. When the actual hard negotiations start, things will be much different, the approach will be very much different, there has to be a give and take by both sides, which is minimally accepted to what is called the common denominator factor," he added.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

S
Sarah B
As an observer, I find the analysis spot on. It's classic negotiation posturing. Both sides are just establishing their opening bids. The real talks haven't even begun.
P
Priya S
India should learn from this. We also face pressure on various fronts. Standing firm on principles is important, but so is pragmatic diplomacy. Hope our MEA is taking notes.
V
Vikram M
The former diplomat makes a valid point about the contradiction in Trump's statements. But I respectfully disagree that Iran can "bear the loss" indefinitely. Their economy is suffering badly. Common people are paying the price.
R
Rohit P
Geopolitics is a chess game. Iran knows its value in the region. The US needs stability in the Middle East for oil and to counter other powers. Both will have to compromise eventually. Good analysis!
M
Michael C
Interesting perspective from an Indian diplomat. The emphasis on civilizational pride is something often missed in Western analysis. For nations with deep history, it's not just about economics.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50