How India's Strategic Silence Benefits US, Israel & Gulf States: Ex-NSA

Former Deputy National Security Advisor Pankaj Saran stated that India's strategic silence on the West Asia conflict has worked in favor of the United States, Israel, and Gulf countries. He explained that India's foreign policy balances its interests with Gulf states and maintains friendly relations with Iran. Saran highlighted that this posture is a political judgment call, referencing Prime Minister Modi's visit to Israel. He concluded that while India has taken a side, history will ultimately judge the decision.

Key Points: India's Silence Aids US, Israel, Gulf: Former Deputy NSA

  • India's silence aids US & Israel
  • Balancing ties with Gulf & Iran
  • Foreign policy driven by strategic interests
  • History will judge the stance
2 min read

"India's silence helped Americans, Israelis, Gulf states": Former Deputy NSA Pankaj Saran on strategic posturing in West Asia

Former Deputy NSA Pankaj Saran explains how India's strategic posturing in West Asia protects its interests with Gulf states, Iran, US & Israel.

"The silence that we have maintained is obviously helpful to the Americans and the Israelis. And to the Gulf states. - Pankaj Saran"

New Delhi, March 31

Amid the developing security situation in West Asia and the Gulf region, Former Deputy National Security Advisor Pankaj Saran on Tuesday noted how India's "silence" has worked in favour of the United States, Israel and Gulf countries, highlighting how such strategic posturing works to ensure India's interests and values are protected.

He made the remarks in a conversation with ANI while responding to a query on whether India's strategic silence is being interpreted as tacit support for the US and Israel.

Noting that he would concur with the view to a certain extent, Saran said, "To some extent. This is an issue where you have interests, and you have values."

He spoke about the growing backlash in global public opinion against the United States over its military actions, especially in Iran.

He emphasised that India's foreign policy is guided by its strategic interests, especially in maintaining ties across the region, including with the Gulf nations and Iran--underlining the balancing of relations as a consistent feature of India's foreign policy.

"Our interests lie with the Gulf states. They also lie with Iran."

He added, "There has been this element in our policy of where you play Iran and Pakistan against each other. So that's why we maintained, among many other reasons, always a channel and friendly relations with Iran. So this is a balance issue."

He recalled Prime Minister Narendra Modi's visit to Israel and said, "Its a judgment call. It's a political decision of what the government wants to do. The Prime Minister went to Israel two days before. So there is that element here. So the silence that we have maintained is obviously helpful to the Americans and the Israelis. Let's put it that way. And to the Gulf states."

He said that while in some senses New Delhi has taken a side, but eventually history would judge whether the decision was correct.

"In some senses, yes, you have taken a side. It'll only be history which will judge whether you took the right decision or not. It's very difficult at this time when we're in the thick of it."

The remarks come as the conflict between US-Israel and Iran has now entered into its second month, with escalated security situation in West Asia and the Gulf region.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

S
Sarah B
As an expat living in Dubai, I appreciate this nuanced approach. The Gulf is home to millions of Indians. Any overt alignment could jeopardize their safety and our crucial economic ties. Silence is pragmatic here.
V
Vikram M
While I understand the realpolitik, I respectfully disagree. There's a difference between strategic silence and moral ambiguity. At some point, India's voice should stand for something clear on the global stage, especially concerning human suffering.
P
Priyanka N
Balancing Iran and the Gulf states is a tightrope walk we've managed for decades. Chabahar port is vital for connectivity, and so are our relations with UAE and Saudi. The government is playing the long game. Fingers crossed it pays off.
R
Rohit P
"History will judge" – that's the key line. It's easy for us to comment from the sidelines. The MEA has access to intelligence and diplomatic channels we don't. For now, trust the professionals to handle this delicate situation.
K
Karthik V
The mention of playing Iran and Pakistan against each other is the real geopolitics. Our foreign policy can't be driven by emotion. It has to be cold, calculated, and in the interest of 1.4 billion Indians. Hard choices, but necessary ones.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50