India warns Security Council inaction undermining public faith in UN
United Nations, July 15
India has warned that people's view of the UN is sinking as it fails to reform the Security Council to make it capable of ending conflicts end human suffering.
"Public perception about the UN has changed adversely in the recent past primarily due to the Security Council's inability to meaningfully intervene in raging conflicts across different parts of the globe", India's Permanent Representative P Harish said on Tuesday.
"The Security Council has been ineffective in putting an end to human suffering among the affected populations", he said, and this calls into question its ability to uphold the foundational principle of maintaining international peace and security.
He was speaking at a ministerial roundtable on "Making Multilateralism Fit for the Future", one of the goals of Pact for the Future at the 2024 world leaders' summit.
The 80-year-old UN architecture created after World War II is inadequate for contemporary global challenges, but "as a collective, the UN has not been able to move the needle on reforming the Security Council", Harish said.
The Intergovernmental Negotiations (IGN) for Council reform "have been limited to an endless cycle of prepared statements", he lamented.
Therefore, the Pact's Action Points on 39 to 42 (that include a call for ending violence, racism and xenophobia; promoting gender equality, and having the Council create effective peacekeeping strategies) "have largely remained on paper", he said.
"This is untenable and must change", he declared.
Harish noted that "India had significant reservations with regard to these action points".
"However", he added, "it was India's constructive spirit that encouraged us to go along broadly with the Pact".
Besides reforming the Council, "the revitalisation of the General Assembly, and the stronger role for ECOSOC (Economic and Social Council of the UN) in advancing sustainable development in its three dimensions - economic, social and environmental" were essential, he said.
On fostering economic development of the Global South, he said, "Our commitment is unwavering to leave no one behind, to mobilise resources where they matter most, and to lead by example".
Turning to the international financial institutions, Harish said they "too must also evolve" and "become more representative, responsive and development-oriented, while preserving their mandates".
"Adequate, affordable and predictable financing remains indispensable for achieving the Sustainable Development Goals", he pointed out.
"India carries this paradigm forward grounded in our civilizational ethos of Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam, or the whole world is a family", he said.
— IANS
Reader Comments
I understand India's frustration, but simply adding more permanent members might not solve the problem. Maybe we need a completely different model for the Security Council - one that's more agile and accountable to all nations, not just a few powerful ones.
The irony is painful - institutions created to prevent war are now stuck in endless discussions while people die in conflicts across Gaza, Ukraine, and Africa. India's 'Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam' philosophy is exactly what the UN needs, not this power-dominated structure. 🙏
While I support India's demand for reform, we must also look inward. India itself needs to improve its own human rights record and conflict resolution mechanisms at home before lecturing others. That said, the UN status quo is indeed unacceptable. #UNSCReform
The UK and France have permanent seats? Come on. India, Brazil, Japan, Germany, and African representation are long overdue. The UN is losing credibility because it can't adapt to the 21st century multipolar world. Well said by India's representative.
'Endless cycle of prepared statements' - that perfectly captures the IGN process. We've been discussing reform for decades while the world changes around us. Kudos to India for speaking truth to power. But will the P5 listen? Probably not. 😤
K We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.