India-US Trade Deal: A "Major Step Forward" But Full Recovery Takes Time

Lisa Curtis, Director of the Centre for New American Security, hailed the new India-US trade deal as a significant boost to bilateral relations. She cautioned, however, that the relationship, strained by months of trade disputes and security disagreements, will not recover overnight. Curtis cited factors like India's reduced Russian oil imports and its recent EU trade pact as influencing the US decision to finalize the agreement. The concluded deal could now open the door for a potential visit by President Trump to India, possibly including a Quad leaders' summit.

Key Points: India-US Trade Deal: A Step Forward, But Ties Need Time

  • Trade deal reduces tariffs on Indian goods to 18%
  • Trust was strained by trade and security disputes
  • Deal may pave way for Trump visit, Quad summit
  • India's EU pact, reduced Russian oil imports influenced US
  • Modi protected Indian farmers in negotiations
4 min read

India-US trade deal is "major step forward", but ties will take time to get "fully back on track": CNAS Director

CNAS Director Lisa Curtis calls the India-US trade deal a major boost but cautions the strained relationship will take time to fully get back on track.

"This is a major step forward, it will take time to get the US-India relationship fully back on track. - Lisa Curtis"

Washington DC, February 4

The Director of the Centre for New American Security, Lisa Curtis, on Tuesday described the recently announced India-US trade deal, in which Washington reduced the tariff on Indian goods to 18 per cent, as a "major step forward" for bilateral ties, while also cautioning that the relationship will take time to fully recover after months of diplomatic strain.

Speaking to ANI about the agreement announced on Monday, Curtis said the deal would provide a significant boost to US-India relations but noted that trust between the two countries had been strained over the past 10 months due to trade disputes and differences over regional security issues.

"The announcement of the conclusion of the trade deal was very welcome and will provide a major boost to US-India relations. This is a big step in the right direction. I don't think that the relationship will turn around overnight. There has been a lot of trust lost over the last 10 months, and there were not only trade problems, but also there have been disagreements between the US and India on the aftermath of the India-Pakistan conflict. While this is a major step forward, it will take time to get the US-India relationship fully back on track," she stated.

Curtis outlined several factors that may have contributed to the agreement's conclusion, including efforts by US Ambassador Sergio Gor to convey the deal's strategic importance to US President Donald Trump.

She also noted India's declining imports of Russian oil, particularly in December, which she said the US administration had noticed and appreciated.

Another factor, Curtis said, was India's recent free trade agreement with the European Union, which concluded last month during the state visit of European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and European Council President Antonio Costa, that demonstrated New Delhi's alternative economic options, potentially prompting Washington to accelerate its own trade engagement.

"In terms of what led to this announcement, it could be several things. Number one, Ambassador Sergio Gor arriving in New Delhi on January 9th, making positive statements over the last several weeks. And that he probably was able to communicate with President Trump and indicate the benefits of the deal, and how important the relationship was, could be one contributing factor. The second contributing factor was the fact that India's imports of Russian oil had been going down, particularly in December, and that was noticed by President Trump and appreciated. And then the third point would be the fact that India concluded a free trade agreement with the EU just last week, which shows that India has some options on the table for its goods. That could have prompted the US to want to speed up its own trade agreement with India," the CNAS director added.

While speaking to ANI, Curtis claimed that the trade deal will benefit both sides, noting that tariffs on Indian goods would be reduced to 18 per cent, which she described as a major positive outcome for India.

She added that while the US sought greater market access for American farmers, Prime Minister Narendra Modi remained firm on protecting Indian farmers.

"This is a good deal for both countries... We're seeing India reduce Russian oil imports, which was a major demand from the United States. On providing US farmers access to the Indian market, Prime Minister Modi stuck to his guns on this one. He [PM Modi] was very clear that he was going to continue to protect Indian farmers. And that indeed seems to be what he has done. So neither side got everything it wanted. But that's the nature of a deal and the compromises that have to be made on each side," she noted.

On the Quad, Curtis said the signing of the trade deal could create renewed momentum, including the possibility of a Quad leaders' summit.

She noted that Trump had previously indicated he would not visit India until the trade agreement was finalised.

"With the deal now done, it does open the door to planning a presidential visit to India," she said, adding that such a visit could potentially include a Quad summit in New Delhi.

"President Trump was clear that he didn't want to make a visit to India until the trade deal was signed. Well, that's now done. So it does open the door for starting that planning for President Trump's visit to India. And I think if that does happen, there will likely be a Quad summit in New Delhi, as was planned last fall," she said.

However, Curtis cautioned that time constraints, particularly President Trump's planned April meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping, could complicate scheduling.

"It's not clear if there is enough time to plan a major visit to India right now," the director added.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

S
Sarah B
Interesting analysis. It seems the EU trade deal really pushed the US to act. Good diplomacy by India to create leverage. A Quad summit in Delhi would be a powerful signal, but let's see if the scheduling works out with Trump's other commitments.
A
Ananya R
Trust takes years to build and months to break. The last 10 months have been rocky. While this deal is a step forward, we must be cautious. The US relationship is important, but we should continue strengthening ties with the EU and other partners. Diversification is our strength.
V
Vikram M
Reducing dependence on Russian oil was a smart move that the US noticed. It shows our foreign policy can be pragmatic. Hope this leads to more technology sharing and investment in manufacturing. "Make in India" needs such partnerships.
K
Karthik V
A respectful criticism: The article focuses a lot on US perspectives. I wish there was more from our MEA or Commerce Ministry officials. We always seem to be reacting to US statements. We need to set the narrative more strongly.
P
Priya S
Good deal! But let's not get too excited. The US has a history of changing its stance based on who is in the White House. We need long-term, stable agreements that survive political changes in both countries. Jai Hind!

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50