India Slams Pakistan at UN for Misusing Self-Determination Over Kashmir

India has strongly criticized Pakistan at the UN General Assembly for repeatedly misusing platforms to push a divisive agenda on Kashmir. Indian diplomat Eldos Punoose stated that the right to self-determination must not be abused to undermine pluralistic democracies like India. He asserted that Jammu and Kashmir is an integral part of India, dismissing Pakistan's references as baseless allegations detached from reality. The exchange occurred as Pakistan's envoy attempted to link Kashmir to discussions on self-determination, despite the issue being largely ignored by other member states.

Key Points: India Slams Pakistan at UN for Misusing Kashmir Issue

  • India rebukes Pakistan at UN
  • Accuses misuse of self-determination
  • Asserts Jammu & Kashmir is integral part of India
  • Highlights Pakistan's isolated stance
2 min read

India slams Pakistan for 'abusing' concept of self-determination for attacks on democracies

India criticizes Pakistan for abusing UN platforms with falsehoods on Kashmir, defending its sovereignty and pluralistic democracy.

"The right to self-determination... must not be abused to encourage secession in pluralistic and democratic states. - Eldos Punoose"

United Nations, Jan 16

India has slammed Pakistan for misusing the concept of self-determination to attack democratic and pluralistic nations by harping on Kashmir with falsehoods.

"At a time when member states have to rise beyond their narrow considerations, Pakistan continues to misuse all platforms and processes in the UN to drive their divisive agenda", Eldos Punoose, a counsellor at India's UN Mission, said on Thursday at the General Assembly.

"The right to self-determination is a fundamental principle enshrined in the UN Charter. However, this right must not be abused to encourage secession in pluralistic and democratic states," he said.

Punoose declared, "Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir, an integral and inalienable part of India".

He was responding to Pakistan's Permanent Representative Asim Iftikhar Ahmad, who referred to Kashmir when the Assembly was discussing Secretary-General Antonio Guterres's report on the work of the UN in the past year.

Regardless of the topic on the agenda, Pakistan repeatedly brings up Kashmir, even though other members ignore its fulminations, letting them slip into irrelevance.

"This forum is no exception either, and Pakistan made an unwarranted reference to the Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir, an integral and inalienable part of India", Punoose said.

"Though habituated, Pakistan would do well if they do not resort to baseless allegations and falsehoods and portrays a picture that is completely detached from reality," he added.

Ahmad, as he has done before, spoke of self-determination for the Palestinian people and sneaked in a reference to Kashmir.

He spoke about respect for UN resolutions.

However, Security Council Resolution 47, adopted on April 21, 1948, demands that Pakistan withdraw its forces and infiltrators from all of Kashmir.

India maintains that a plebiscite in Kashmir is now irrelevant because the people of Kashmir have made clear their allegiance to India by participating in elections and by electing the leaders of the territory.

Ahmad repeated Pakistan's opposition to expanding the Security Council's permanent membership solely because of its animosity towards India.

It puts its odds with the majority of UN members, especially the African countries, who have been denied permanent representation because of the colonial hold over the formation of the world organisation.

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

S
Sarah B
As an observer, it's clear India is making a valid legal point about the misuse of the UN Charter. The principle of self-determination isn't a tool for breaking up stable democracies. Pakistan's stance seems stuck in the past.
V
Vikram M
Perfect rebuttal. They keep bringing up old resolutions but forget the one that asks *them* to vacate Kashmir first! Our elections in J&K show where the people's allegiance lies. Pakistan should focus on its own failing economy and terrorism.
P
Priyanka N
While I fully support India's position, I sometimes wish our diplomacy was a bit more forward-looking. We are always reacting to Pakistan's provocations. Can we set a more positive, future-oriented agenda at these forums?
R
Rohit P
The world sees through this now. No one even pays attention when Pakistan speaks at the UN anymore. It's become a joke. Their opposition to UNSC expansion just because India might benefit shows their petty mindset. Good on our diplomat for stating facts clearly.
M
Michael C
Interesting to see the historical context of Resolution 47 mentioned. It's a complex issue, but the argument about participation in elections being a form of self-determination is a compelling one in the modern context.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50