India to pursue PTAs over FTAs with developing economies like South Africa: Senior government official
By Sailesh Yadav, New Delhi, August 12
India will pursue Preferential Trade Agreements rather than full-fledged Free Trade Agreements with developing economies such as South Africa, opting for a calibrated approach that opens up only select product categories rather than deep, across-the-board market access, according to a senior government official.
The official told ANI that South Africa is not a highly developed economy and a full FTA would require a much deeper opening up of the Indian market, a move that may not necessarily serve India's interests. Instead, India has decided to pursue a PTA route, under which both sides will identify specific products of mutual strength and interest: South Africa will get market access in areas where it has strengths, while India will secure access in products of its own interest.
A Preferential Trade Agreement (PTA) is a trade pact between countries that reduces tariffs and other trade barriers on selected goods traded among member nations. PTA does not remove all tariffs and usually applies only to a selected list of products.
The government is also moving ahead with PTA negotiations with Mercosur, the South American trade bloc comprising Brazil and other member nations. Discussions are also being explored for a possible PTA with Mexico and Kenya, while Ecuador has independently approached India expressing interest in a full FTA.
On Chile, the official said the Commerce Secretary is scheduled to travel to the country by the end of August or next month to assess whether a mutually beneficial deal can be reached. "If we get a good deal, we are on."
The official was sharply critical of how free trade agreements were negotiated under the previous UPA government, alleging that stakeholder consultations during that period were largely superficial.
Citing the ASEAN agreement as an example, the official said businesses were reportedly promised morning discussions before finalisation of the deal, but instead received a message at night informing them that the signing ceremony was scheduled for the next day leaving industry representatives with no real opportunity to weigh in.
In contrast, the official said, the current government ensures that all concerned stakeholders are consulted and taken on board before any trade agreement is finalised, describing the approach as a "whole of the government, whole of stakeholders" model of negotiation.
Illustrating this approach, the official pointed to two recent stakeholder meetings - one on expanding India's shipbuilding and shipbreaking capacity, and another on addressing urea diversion - both of which brought together relevant ministries, industry bodies, and private sector players to arrive at coordinated action plans, reflecting what the official described as a more inclusive and consultative style of policymaking compared to earlier trade negotiation practices.
— ANI
Reader Comments
As someone who works in trade policy, this is actually a very pragmatic move. South Africa's economy is quite different from ours - a full FTA would mean opening up dairy, agriculture, and pharma in ways that might not be mutually beneficial. PTA allows both sides to cherry-pick what works. Good strategic thinking.
The criticism of UPA's approach is well-deserved. I remember reading about how the ASEAN FTA was rushed through without proper consultation. Industries like textiles and dairy were left high and dry. At least now there's a "whole of government" approach which is more inclusive. But let's see if the implementation matches the talk.
South Africa has strong mining and agricultural sectors. If we're not careful, they could push for tariff cuts on products that compete with our domestic industry. The PTA route gives us a safety valve - we can always renegotiate if things don't go as planned. Smart move by the commerce ministry.
I'm a bit skeptical about how "inclusive" the current consultations really are. They claim stakeholder engagement, but are they actually listening to small-scale producers or just big industry bodies? Let's see if the PTA with Mercosur and others actually benefits the common person or just corporate interests.
Good to see India being more strategic in trade deals. We've learned from past mistakes where we gave away too much for too little. PTA with developing economies makes sense - we can protect our sensitive sectors while still engaging. Also interesting that Ecuador wants a full FTA - that shows our growing economic clout.
We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.