Grassroot Reservation Key for Equal Opportunities in Governance: Lt Gen Kanitkar

Lieutenant General (retd) Madhuri Kanitkar asserts that reservation is essential at the grassroots level in governance and civil organizations due to a lack of equal opportunities. She views the recent defeat of the women's reservation bill as a temporary setback, believing the idea is too positive and wholesome to be abandoned. Drawing parallels with the armed forces, she notes that initial apprehensions were often logistical, not about competence or gender. Kanitkar emphasizes that once a system provides genuine equal opportunity, the need for reservation naturally disappears.

Key Points: Lt Gen Madhuri Kanitkar on Grassroot Reservation for Women

  • Women's reservation bill defeat temporary
  • Grassroot reservation stimulates young girls
  • Equal opportunities negate need for reservation
  • Armed forces saw initial logistical apprehensions
  • Competence appreciated when opportunities are equal
3 min read

Grassroot reservation in governance must to create equal opportunities: Lt Gen (retd) Madhuri Kanitkar (IANS Exclusive)

Retired Lt Gen Madhuri Kanitkar argues reservation is necessary at grassroots in governance to create equal opportunities and empower women voters.

"Once opportunities are equal, I don't think reservation is required. - Lt Gen (retd) Madhuri Kanitkar"

New Delhi, April 18

Lieutenant General Madhuri Kanitkar, a retired General Officer in the Indian Army and the third woman to achieve a Three-star rank, on Saturday mentioned reservation as "necessary from the grassroot" when it comes to civil organisations or governance. She termed it as important since according to her "equal opportunities are not provided in these sectors".

During an interaction with IANS, Kanitkar spoke about the defeat of the Constitution (131st Amendment) Bill in the Lok Sabha.

She mentioned the Bill's collapse as a "temporary thing".

"I don't think it's there to stay because the idea of this reservation for women is so wholesome and so important and in such a positive direction," she said.

She highlighted that anything new would have "resistance and is looked at with a lot of apprehension".

"You don't expect everyone to agree on things. So, I think it's a question of 'Der Hai Andher Nahi' (it is late but never too late)," she added.

According to Kanitkar, reservation will be a big thing for the women voters as then it won't be like "women are going to vote only for the men to come and rule them".

She said that it would give the women a feeling of importance and would "stimulate young girls to get into this field because we are starting at grassroot levels".

The former Army officer also drew a comparison between the political representation of women and their inclusion in the armed forces.

She mentioned that even in the armed forces, more than resistance, there were apprehensions and those were not purely because of gender or competence.

"They were also because of the logistic support that's required. When you put women in combat roles, you need to have certain infrastructure. This is not the case in politics, right? You don't need to sort of ensure that they're in high altitude positions, whether there are toilets for women. I mean, these are very basic issues," Kanitkar said.

"Once opportunities are equal, I don't think reservation is required," she noted.

Speaking about the challenges she faced while navigating through the male-dominated spaces, Kanitkar attributed her success to two things, "One is that competence was always appreciated. At the younger level, there were equal opportunities."

Moreover, she emphasised that there was "no selection bias".

"Whether it's the military courses or post-graduation, for all these the opportunities were equal. So once you have given equal opportunities, as you go along the way, you bring in a certain confidence to the thing and you don't expect reservations anymore," the former Army officer said.

Kanitkar also made an observation about the huge gap between the appointment of the three women generals in the Army.

She also appreciated the increase in female appointments in combat roles.

"Then see how exponentially it has grown after that. Today, the armed forces, I mean, the medical corps, our DG AFMS is a woman, the DG Navy is a woman, the DG Army was a woman," she said.

Therefore, "It is empowering them from the grassroots which created leaders in the future. It was not a reservation," she stressed.

However, the former Army officer said that in a civil organisation or governance, "reservation is important from the grassroot because equal opportunities are not provided."

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

R
Rohit P
I have mixed feelings. While I respect Lt. Gen. Kanitkar's incredible achievements, I'm not fully convinced reservation at the grassroots in politics is the only answer. It can sometimes lead to tokenism. Shouldn't the focus be on fixing the education and social systems first so women are empowered to compete on equal footing?
A
Ananya R
"Der Hai Andher Nahi" – what a powerful way to put it! The Women's Reservation Bill has been pending for decades. Seeing a leader from the Army, where they made inclusion work without reservation (in officer roles), advocate for it in governance tells you how broken our political system is. It's a wake-up call.
D
David E
Interesting perspective from a high-achieving professional. Her point about logistics in the army vs. politics is stark. In politics, the barriers are often social and financial, not physical infrastructure. A grassroots reservation could help break the old networks that dominate local governance.
K
Karthik V
True empowerment comes from competence and confidence, not just a seat. But as she says, if the door is locked, you need a key to open it first. Reservation at the panchayat level has shown positive results in many states. Maybe that's the key for higher governance too. Her life is proof that given the chance, women excel.
S
Sneha F
It's so refreshing to hear this from someone who reached the top on merit in a tough field. She's not asking for reservation for herself, but for the millions of women at the bottom who don't have the platform she had. This is about justice, not charity. More power to her for speaking up! 💪

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50