Ex-Army Chief Naravane Denies Abandonment During 2020 China Standoff

Former Army Chief General Manoj Mukund Naravane has denied claims that the military was left without direction during the 2020 China standoff. He clarified that the Prime Minister's instruction to "do what you think is right" was a significant gesture of trust, not a lack of orders. Naravane emphasized that he felt the entire country and army were behind him throughout the crisis. He also stated that Indian soldiers have standing authority to open fire in self-defence when personal safety or territorial integrity is at stake.

Key Points: Naravane: Army Had Full Govt Backing in China Standoff

  • Gen Naravane denies being abandoned during 2020 China standoff
  • He calls PM's "do what you think is right" a gesture of trust
  • Soldiers have standing authority to open fire in self-defence
  • He credits subordinate commanders for India's advantage at negotiations
2 min read

Govt and country backed army during China standoff: General Naravane

Former Indian Army Chief Gen Manoj Mukund Naravane refutes claims of isolation during the 2020 China standoff, calling PM's directive a gesture of trust.

"I felt the entire country and the army were behind me - General Manoj Mukund Naravane"

New Delhi, April 23

Former Indian Army Chief General Manoj Mukund Naravane has formally addressed the political controversy surrounding the 2020 China standoff, firmly denying claims that the military was left without direction during the crisis.

The remarks serve as a direct counter to assertions made by Congress leader Rahul Gandhi, who had previously suggested that the General was abandoned by the political leadership at the height of the tensions at Rechin La pass.

The controversy stemmed from General Naravane's unpublished memoir, Four Stars of Destiny, which reportedly noted that the Prime Minister's instruction during the face-off was to do what you think is right.

While the opposition interpreted this as a lack of clear orders, General Naravane told NDTV that he viewed the directive as a significant gesture of trust.

He clarified that he interpreted the message as being granted total freedom of operation, which he deemed the correct decision, given that the military hierarchy possesses the best knowledge of ground realities and troop capabilities.

General Naravane dismissed the idea that he was isolated, explaining that while leadership can feel lonely, it does not equate to being abandoned.

He emphasised that he felt the entire country and the army were behind him, and that any course of action he chose would have carried full government backing.

Addressing the specific question of whether there was a requirement for an explicit order to shoot, the former Chief stated that Indian soldiers have always held standing authority to open fire in self-defence.

He noted that if personal safety or the integrity of positions were at stake, troops were at full liberty to act, leaving no doubt in the minds of those on the front lines.

Regarding his first book, which remains under review by the Ministry of Defence, the General maintained a principled stance, refusing to comment on its specific contents to avoid a backdoor entry into public discourse while the official process is ongoing.

He noted that he has moved on and has recently released a new work titled The Curious and the Classified.

Reflecting on the 2020 standoff, he credited the resolute action of his subordinate commanders for India's eventual advantage at the negotiating table, reaffirming that faith and trust between the government and the armed forces remained a two-way street throughout the crisis.

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priya S
As a citizen, I'm relieved to hear that our soldiers had full backing. But I do wish the government had been more transparent during the actual standoff. The public was kept in the dark for too long, which created space for unnecessary speculation. Still, respect to General Naravane for setting the record straight.
M
Michael C
Interesting how this is coming out now through an interview rather than the memoir itself. The Defence Ministry review process seems to be taking ages. Meanwhile, the political circus continues. At least the soldiers on the ground knew what they were doing. Respect from across the border of ideology!
S
Siddharth J
This clarifies everything! The opposition was just trying to score political points by twisting the General's words. "Do what you think is right" - that's what you say when you trust someone completely. Our jawans are heroes, no question about it. Glad Naravane ji put his foot down and spoke the truth. 🙏
R
Rohit L
I'm a bit conflicted here. While I respect the General's clarification, the fact that this had to be explained in an interview shows there was confusion somewhere. The government should have been more proactive in communicating with the public. But yes, our army knows its job - they don't need politicians telling them how to defend the nation.
K
Karthik V
What a dignified response from General Naravane! He's handled this with class - not getting into a political slugfest but simply stating facts. The part about feeling the whole country behind him really moved me. That's the spirit of our armed forces! And kudos to the PM for trusting our military leadership. Team India! 🚩

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50