Former Karnataka CM Bommai seeks relaxation in crop insurance rules as 'farmers pushed out of insurance net'
Bengaluru, July 16
Former Karnataka Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai on Wednesday wrote a formal letter to Karnataka Chief Minister DK Shivakumar, urging the state government to relax the strict rules surrounding the Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana and the Restructured Weather-Based Crop Insurance Scheme.
He highlighted that a new government rule mandating both loanee and non-loanee farmers to compulsorily submit a "Self-Declaration Letter" has put farmers in a severe spot. Citing official correspondence from the Karnataka Commissioner of Agriculture and the Union Government, Bommai expressed deep concern in his letter that these newly introduced rules could completely push small and marginalised farmers out of the protective net of crop insurance.
In his letter, the former Chief Minister identified 17 key technical and procedural issues that he claimed could push vulnerable farmers out of the protective net of crop insurance.
He pointed out that minor typos made by cyber centre operators during data entry are being labelled as "false declarations," leading to the outright rejection of claims. He further alleged that insurance companies are "penalising farmers for banks' negligence," where banks fail to update loan repayment statuses in their software, causing farmers to be wrongly accused of misrepresentation.
"Insurance companies are seizing premiums and forfeiting compensation by dragging out verification till the end of the season, only to deny claims on technical grounds at the last minute," Bommai noted. He also flagged the "misexploitation of Joint Khata records," noting that if one family member has a loan, insurance companies are declaring other joint holders ineligible as "non-loanees," effectively betraying the farmers by linking a single loan to an entire survey number.
The letter also highlighted the "Double Loan Dilemma" faced by those borrowing from both cooperative societies and nationalised banks, and the confusion during "Khata transfer delays" following a landowner's death. Bommai also raised concerns over "Excuses over Crop Changes," noting that when farmers sow low-moisture crops due to monsoon delays, insurance firms cite "Data Mismatch" to refuse payouts.
He also highlighted the difficulties faced by tenant farmers and non-resident landowners in securing necessary signatures for the self-declaration forms.
The letter also mentioned structural issues, including persistent server crashes on the National Crop Insurance Portal (NCIP) and the fear of legal action triggered by the strict warnings on the declaration forms. "Exasperated by these tedious and complicated procedures, many poor farmers are opting to skip crop insurance altogether, exposing themselves to catastrophic financial risks," Bommai warned.
Pointing out these highly complex technical and procedural anomalies, Basavaraj Bommai has urged the state government to immediately simplify these rigid rules to protect the livelihood of the state's farmers.
— ANI
Reader Comments
As someone from a farming family in Hassan, I can tell you the self-declaration form is a nightmare for elderly farmers who can barely read Kannada, leave alone fill a complex form. The government needs to simplify this or at least have village accountants help with it. Farmers should not be penalized for the system's failures. 😡
Fair criticism from Bommai but let's not forget his own government's track record on farmer issues. The point about joint khata records is valid though — how can one family member's loan make everyone ineligible? That's just insurance companies looking for loopholes to deny claims. Both parties need to work together to fix this mess.
The "double loan dilemma" is very real. My uncle in Mandya took loans from both a cooperative and a bank, and when his crop failed, both institutions blamed each other. Insurance said he was "over-leveraged" and rejected the claim. Farmers are being squeezed from all sides. The state must step in and simplify rules. 🌾
I work with an NGO in North Karnataka, and the server crash issue on NCIP is a daily reality. Farmers stand in line for hours only to be told "system down." The fear of legal action from those intimidating warning letters is real too. This needs an urgent fix, not just a letter. Kudos to Bommai for raising it, bureaucrats must act now.
Classic passing the buck — insurance companies blame banks, banks blame farmers, and farmers suffer. The monsoon delays are becoming more
We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.