Dialogue promotes healthy democracy: Delhi Speaker Vijender Gupta
New Delhi, June 20
Delhi Assembly Speaker Vijendra Gupta said on Saturday that constructive dialogue remains the cornerstone of a healthy democracy and a harmonious society.
Addressing the inaugural session of the two-day National Seminar on "Vartaman Samay Mein Shastrarth", Gupta added that the current times are dominated by social media that provides every individual a platform to express opinion but people must cultivate the ability to listen to differing viewpoints.
"Democracy is strengthened when debate is guided by dignity, logic and facts; 'Shastrarth' is not about defeating an opponent but discovering the truth," the Delhi Assembly Speaker said.
The seminar was organised by the Indian Council of Philosophical Research (ICPR) in collaboration with Bharat Bodh Kendra at the India Habitat Centre in New Delhi.
The Delhi Assembly Speaker emphasised that the revival of India's ancient tradition of Shastrarth is not merely a philosophical imperative but a social and democratic necessity in contemporary times.
Addressing scholars, academicians and distinguished guests, Gupta described Shastrarth as the very soul of India's knowledge tradition.
Referring to the dialogues of the Upanishads and the historic debate between Adi Shankaracharya and Mandana Mishra, he said that Indian civilisation has always accorded the highest place to reasoned dialogue, intellectual inquiry and the pursuit of truth.
He added that in the Indian tradition, truth was never imposed but tested through logic and debate, giving rise to the timeless principle, "Vade Vade Jayate Tattva Bodhah" -- the realisation of truth emerges through discussion and deliberation.
Expressing concern over the contemporary discourse ecosystem, the Delhi Assembly Speaker remarked that while the present age is rich in information, it is increasingly witnessing a decline in patience, listening and meaningful dialogue.
Drawing parallels between Shastrarth and democratic institutions, Gupta said that legislative debates represent a modern manifestation of the ancient tradition of intellectual discourse.
He added that the objective of democracy is not fulfilled merely by the formation of a government through majority support, rather, it reaches its true essence when diverse viewpoints are expressed and deliberated upon in the Legislature.
Meaningful discussions, he noted, generate intellectual churning that ultimately leads to better governance and informed decision-making.
Gupta underscored the distinction between Shastrarth and mere argumentation, saying that the objective of Shastrarth is the search for truth rather than the defeat or humiliation of an opponent.
He said that India's civilisational ethos values openness, fairness and impartiality, citing the role of Bharati, wife of Mandana Mishra, as the adjudicator in the celebrated debate between Adi Shankaracharya and Mandana Mishra.
He highlighted that values such as self-discipline, sacrifice, compassion and dialogue have been central to Indian culture and continue to offer guidance in addressing contemporary challenges.
Gupta expressed confidence that the deliberations over the two days would help explore ways to revive and contextualise the Shastrarth tradition for modern times.
— IANS
Reader Comments
I appreciate the sentiment but talk is cheap. Our Assembly sessions are often reduced to walkouts and sloganeering. When will we see actual constructive debate in Delhi Vidhan Sabha? Hope this isn't just a photo op. 🤔
As someone who teaches philosophy in the US, I find this absolutely fascinating. The concept of Shastrarth as truth-seeking rather than adversarial debate is something Western discourse desperately needs. India's intellectual traditions are truly profound.
Vede Vede Jayate Tattva Bodhah — such a powerful principle! Our Upanishads and debates like Shankaracharya vs Mandana Mishra show how we valued logic and evidence. If only our TV debates had even 10% of that spirit instead of all this noise and breaking chairs. 😄
Interesting how ancient traditions align with modern democratic ideals. I'd love to see this "Shastrarth" model applied in international diplomacy — imagine debates focused on truth rather than winning! But actions speak louder than words, let's see if Delhi Assembly actually changes.
Lovely concept but hypocritical coming from a BJP leader whose party often bulldozes opposition in Parliament. However, the idea itself is noble — dialogue over diatribe, logic over loudness. Let's hope all parties take this seriously. 🙏
N We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.