Former Envoy: BRICS Consensus Difficult but Achievable Amid West Asia Crisis

Former envoy Rajiv Bhatia says India faces a challenging but achievable task in forging consensus at the BRICS Foreign Ministers' meeting amid divisions over the Iran-Israel conflict. He notes securing consensus on three key elements is diplomatically feasible: concern over the conflict, recognition of global impact, and BRICS facilitating dialogue. The meeting sends a two-fold message: nations should resolve differences through dialogue, and BRICS will survive to deepen economic cooperation. India hosts the meeting on May 14-15, highlighting its role in steering the expanded multilateral grouping.

Key Points: BRICS Consensus Difficult but Achievable: Former Envoy

  • India faces challenge forging BRICS consensus amid Iran-Israel conflict
  • Former envoy Rajiv Bhatia says task difficult but achievable
  • Key elements: concern over conflict, global impact, BRICS dialogue
  • Meeting sends message on diplomacy, BRICS survival
3 min read

Consensus difficult but achievable at BRICS meet, says former envoy

Former envoy Rajiv Bhatia says forging consensus at BRICS Foreign Ministers' meeting is challenging but possible amid Iran-Israel conflict and West Asia tensions.

"Securing consensus on three key elements is within the realm of diplomatic feasibility - Rajiv Bhatia"

By Ayushi Agarwal, New Delhi, May 13

India will face a challenging but achievable task in forging consensus at the upcoming BRICS Foreign Ministers' meeting amid sharp divisions within the grouping over the Iran-Israel conflict and the wider geopolitical churn in West Asia, Former ambassador and distinguished fellow at Gateway house, Rajiv Bhatia said.

Speaking ahead of the BRICS meeting here, Bhatia said India, as the current chair, would have to navigate competing positions within the bloc while ensuring that the grouping remains focused on dialogue and stability.

"For obvious reasons, it is a difficult but not an impossible task," Bhatia said, adding, "Securing consensus on three key elements is within the realm of diplomatic feasibility -- serious concern over the ill effects of the conflict, recognition that much of the world beyond the warring sides is also affected, and acknowledgement that BRICS must facilitate dialogue and reconciliation among its members."

The comments come at a time when escalating tensions in West Asia have triggered concerns over regional stability, energy supplies and global trade routes. The Strait of Hormuz -- a critical oil shipping lane -- has emerged as a particular concern for countries such as India that remain heavily dependent on energy imports.

Bhatia said the crisis presents BRICS with both "an opportunity and a responsibility" to coordinate responses to strategic disruptions affecting the Global South.

"I suggest that the five founding members take a well-conceived initiative soon," he said, indicating that the grouping could play a larger role in discussions around energy security and maritime stability.

India's decision to host the meeting amid growing global uncertainty also carries a wider diplomatic message, according to Bhatia.

"The message is two-fold," he said, adding, "One, nations must behave as responsible adults and resolve their differences and disputes through dialogue and diplomacy rather than by using drones and missiles. Two, BRICS will survive this and revert to its original mission to deepen economic cooperation among its members and their Global South family."

Notably, India is poised to command the global diplomatic stage as it prepares to host the BRICS Foreign Ministers' Meeting on May 14 and 15. Serving as a defining moment for the bloc, the summit further cements New Delhi's role in steering the future of this expanded multilateral grouping during its high-profile chairship.

According to the programme released by the MEA on Tuesday, the visiting dignitaries are expected to arrive at the venue at 10 am on Thursday. The diplomatic proceedings will commence shortly after, as the "first session of the meeting will begin at 10.30 am at the same venue".

In a move highlighting the strategic importance of the summit, the ministers will then head to Seva Teerth at 1 pm to participate in a "Joint Call on the Prime Minister".

The afternoon will see the delegations return to Bharat Mandapam, where the "second session of the BRICS Foreign Ministers' Meeting is scheduled for 3.10 pm". The first day of deliberations will conclude with a dinner hosted by EAM Jaishankar at 7 pm, followed by the "third session of the meeting will commence at 10 am" on Friday, 15 May.

- ANI

Share this article:

Reader Comments

P
Priya S
Finally, BRICS is talking about real issues affecting the Global South! For too long, the West has dominated the narrative on conflicts. India's message about nations acting like "responsible adults" is spot on. Drones and missiles don't solve anything – only dialogue does. The fact that we are chairing this during such turbulent times just shows how important India is on the world stage. Proud moment for all Indians! 🙌
V
Vikram M
While I appreciate India's diplomatic efforts, let's not ignore the elephant in the room. BRICS has become a club of countries with often conflicting interests. Russia wants to use it to counter the West, China wants to expand its influence, and Iran wants to isolate Israel. Can India genuinely forge consensus when the West Asia crisis is so polarizing? I hope I'm wrong, but this seems more about photo-ops than real problem-solving. Still, credit to India for trying – our soft power is unmatched.
S
Siddharth J
People underestimate how hard it is to host such meetings. The logistics alone are mind-boggling – coordinating schedules of multiple foreign ministers, security arrangements, and handling egos. And then you have the content part where everyone wants their point of view to dominate. Bhatia is right – consensus is difficult but achievable. I think the key for India is to focus on the common ground: all BRICS members want stable energy markets, free trade routes, and no nuclear escalation. Build from there. Kudos to MEA for pulling this off amidst global chaos.
K
Kavya N
It's refreshing to see BRICS focus on the Global South instead of just being an anti-Western bloc. But I am a bit skeptical – can BRICS really act? The organization has no enforcement mechanism, and everyone keeps saying "dialogue and reconciliation" without specifying how. That said, India's role as a neutral-ish chair is perfect. We have

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50