Cleric Backs Women's Reservation Bill But Cautions Muslim Women on Politics

Maulana Mufti Shahabuddin Razvi Barelvi has expressed support for the Women's Reservation Bill, praising Prime Minister Narendra Modi's proactive stance on promoting women's political empowerment. However, he simultaneously advised Muslim women against entering politics, arguing that Islam discourages it to protect their dignity and safety. He described contemporary politics as a "swamp" of deceit and manipulation, vastly different from the past. While endorsing greater legislative representation for women, he urged Muslim women to exercise caution and refrain from direct political engagement.

Key Points: Cleric Supports Women's Bill, Advises Muslim Women on Politics

  • Supports Women's Reservation Bill
  • Cautions Muslim women on political entry
  • Cites Islamic perspective and safety concerns
  • Contrasts today's politics with the past
2 min read

Cleric endorses Reservation Bill, advises restraint for Muslim women

Maulana Mufti Shahabuddin Razvi Barelvi endorses the Women's Reservation Bill but advises Muslim women against entering politics from an Islamic perspective.

"Islam prevents Muslim women from getting trapped in the quagmire of politics. - Maulana Mufti Shahabuddin Razvi Barelvi"

Bareilly, April 15

While expressing support for the Women's Reservation Bill, All India Muslim Jamaat National President Maulana Mufti Shahabuddin Razvi Barelvi offered a nuanced view, endorsing greater representation of women in legislatures but cautioning Muslim women against entering politics from an Islamic perspective.

Speaking to IANS, Razvi said that Prime Minister Narendra Modi has been proactive regarding the proposed amendments to the Women's Reservation Bill and is keen on ensuring that women play a larger role in governance, particularly in the 2029 Lok Sabha elections.

"Prime Minister Narendra Modi has been very active and is keen that women get elected in the 2029 Lok Sabha elections and take leadership roles in Parliament. He wants to promote women's empowerment and ensure greater representation of women in politics. I support this, as it is a positive step -- once 33 per cent reservation is implemented, more women will reach both Parliament and state Assemblies," he said.

However, the cleric also highlighted concerns being raised within sections of the Muslim community, particularly among youth and women, regarding the compatibility of political participation with Islamic principles.

"Many Muslim youth and women are asking what the political perspective is. From a political point of view and an Islamic perspective, I would like to say that Islam prevents Muslim women from getting trapped in the quagmire of politics," he stated.

Elaborating further, Razvi argued that the current nature of politics may pose challenges to the dignity and safety of women. "In politics, their dignity, respect and safety may not remain secure. There could be a lack of modesty and exposure; therefore, Islam discourages Muslim women from entering politics," he said.

Drawing a contrast between past and present political environments, he remarked that contemporary politics has changed significantly. "Today's politics is vastly different from the politics of the past -- the difference is as vast as that between the earth and the sky. Today's politics is like a swamp; any woman who enters it may get trapped in this web of deceit and manipulation," he added.

While reiterating his support for the legislative measure aimed at enhancing women's participation, the cleric advised Muslim women to exercise caution and, in his view, refrain from engaging directly in political activities.

- IANS

Share this article:

Reader Comments

A
Arjun K
The Women's Reservation Bill is a historic step for India. Every community's women should benefit. If politics is a "swamp," then we should clean it, not tell half our population to stay out. More women in politics will change its nature for the better.
S
Sarah B
As someone living in India, I find this perspective concerning. It seems to use safety concerns to justify limiting opportunities. Many Muslim women are highly educated and capable leaders. Their voices are needed in our democracy.
R
Rohit P
Mixed feelings here. I support the Maulana's endorsement of the bill - it's a good thing. But his advice to Muslim women feels paternalistic. My own sister is in local politics and it's empowering for her. Safety is an issue for ALL women in public life, not just one community.
F
Fatima Khan
I am a Muslim woman and I respectfully disagree with the Maulana's caution. Islam teaches us to seek knowledge and contribute to society. Politics is one way to do that. We have examples of strong Muslim women leaders globally. We can participate with dignity and on our own terms. 🙏
V
Vikram M
The core issue is the state of our politics, which he rightly calls a swamp. The solution isn't to keep women out, but to get more good people—men AND women—from all backgrounds to enter and reform it. The bill is a step in that direction.

We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

Leave a Comment

Minimum 50 characters 0/50