"Any protest that hampers patient's treatment is inappropriate:" Maharashtra CM Devendra Fadnavis on doctors' strike
Mumbai, August 6
Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis on Thursday addressed the doctors' strike over the government's proposal concerning the registration of homoeopathy practitioners, declaring that any protest that hampers the treatment and relief of patients is inappropriate.
Addressing a press conference, the Maharashtra Chief Minister emphasised that all doctors, regardless of the medical system they practice, are equal for the state government and that no distinction is made among them.
"I believe that protests should not be conducted in a manner that disrupts patient care. Any protest that hampers the treatment and relief of patients is inappropriate...For the state government, all doctors, regardless of the medical system they practice are equal, and we make no distinction among them. Doctors serving in our medical colleges and hospitals are especially important to us. I would like to assure them that the government has no intention of treating them unfairly," said CM Devendra Fadnavis.
Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis' remarks came after the Maharashtra Association of Resident Doctors (MARD) announced an indefinite statewide strike over the government's proposal to grant Maharashtra Medical Council (MMC) registration to homoeopathy practitioners.
In a statement, MARD said that while emergency and casualty services would continue during the initial 24 hours in the interest of patient safety, all OPD services, routine duties, and academic activities at government medical college hospitals across all districts would remain suspended.
The agitation received full support from several bodies, including the Indian Medical Association (IMA), Maharashtra State Resident Doctors Association (MSRDA), Association of State Medical Interns (ASMI), Maharashtra Association of Gazetted Medical Officers' Group-A (MAGMO), and the Maharashtra State Medical Teachers Association (MSMTA).
Earlier, the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation-Maharashtra Association of Resident Doctors (BMC MARD) on Thursday announced the escalation of its protest across BMC hospitals after meetings with senior civic and state health officials failed to result in concrete assurances on its key demands.
According to Maharashtra Association of Resident Doctors, its representatives met senior Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation officials led by Deputy Municipal Commissioner (Public Health) Sharad Ughade to discuss long-pending issues concerning resident doctors, including the National Medical Commission (NMC) leave policy, tuition fee exemption, stipend, hostel and canteen facilities, and other welfare-related concerns.
According to the association, the government assured the delegation that the matter would be placed before the Chief Minister. However, BMC MARD said no concrete decision or written assurance was provided during the meeting.
Following the discussions, it was announced that it would intensify its agitation and withdraw several routine medical services across BMC hospitals with effect from August 6 until further notice.
The services withdrawn include routine outpatient department (OPD) services, routine inpatient department (IPD) services, academic activities, elective surgeries, elective procedures, Central Laboratory services and Fever OPD services.
The association clarified that all emergency and critical healthcare services would continue without interruption. These include emergency and casualty services, trauma care, intensive care units (ICUs), labour rooms, emergency surgeries, lifesaving procedures, Emergency Laboratory (E-Lab) services and all other essential emergency services.
The association reiterated its key demands, including the immediate suspension of the Maharashtra Medical Council registration of CCMP-qualified BHMS practitioners, enactment and strict enforcement of legislation prohibiting cross-pathy by non-allopathic practitioners, and early resolution of pending issues concerning BMC resident doctors, including implementation of the new leave policy, tuition fee exemption, improved hostel facilities, hygienic canteen services and enhanced campus security.
— ANI
Reader Comments
As someone who has lived in both India and the US, I find this fascinating. In America, doctors' unions regularly go on strike, but the impact here feels more personal because of the sheer volume of patients in government hospitals. The CM's point is valid—when you're dealing with lives, politics should take a backseat. Hope both sides find a middle ground soon.
I'm a homoeopathy practitioner myself, and I completely understand why the resident doctors are upset. Cross-pathy is a serious concern. But honestly, striking isn't the answer. We need dialogue, not disruption. The CM saying all doctors are equal is a good sign, but the MARD should push for proper regulatory reforms instead of putting patients at risk. 🙏
Typical political statement from Fadnavis—sounds balanced but doesn't address the core issue. The doctors are worried about quality of care and professional standards, and that's a legitimate concern. However, I do agree with the CM on one thing: strikes that hurt patients are not the way to go. MARD should negotiate harder instead of escalating. The government needs to come up with a clearer policy on this.
Living in a small town near Mumbai, I rely on the government hospital for everything. When I heard about this strike, my heart sank. Already our hospitals are overburdened, and now this. I really hope the doctors and the government sort this out quickly. Patients shouldn't suffer because of administrative disputes. The CM's statement gives me some hope, but actions will speak louder than words.
We welcome thoughtful discussions from our readers. Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.